Re: O.e. Prop size
yeah that sounds about right, considering you have more gear ratio in the drive than i have. If you had your normal load in the boat 5000 to me doesnt seem bad unless you want all out speed. You can always pull the throttle back a little to keep from over revving, and have a little low end power for towing.
Was the 19 pitch aluminum? Its hard to compare changing props how one will act compared to hte other of a different family, brand etc. I woul almost guess a stainless 19 will not turn the revs an aluminum will but it all varies.