rebuild or replace

mjm91673

Cadet
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
13
Currently have a 22 ft pontoon with a 1984 70hp evinrude. Compression is low on bottom cylinder (125psi in comparison to 155 on other 2), water pump should be replaced and carbs should be gone through. Should I have motor gone COMPLETELY through or should I go shopping for a different motor?

Thanks
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Re: rebuild or replace

That decision depends on the quality of workmanship of whoever is going to do the overhaul, along with the total accurate estimate of repairs which could then be compared to a new engine.

The only way to obtain a accurate estimate unfortunately is to tear the engine completely down whereas the parts needed can be totaled and coupled with the remaining labor time required to finish. You would be expected to pay for the tear down and estimate time.
 

mjm91673

Cadet
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
Messages
13
Re: rebuild or replace

OK I'll ammend my post, What would the going rate be to completely go through this motor by a trained tech. parts and labor I know this will be the cheaper way, but will it be worth it. Assuming the cost of rebuild would make nice down payment on different motor
 

Dennisanoka

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
252
Re: rebuild or replace

If you do a little searching on this site you'll lean that sometimes low compression can be caused by sticky rings. If you free up the rings your compression may come back, that is done by the decarbing process. There are several places here you'll find the recomended process. In my only semi educated opinion, in your case I would certainly give it a try. It may cost you $20 max. Next thing if that does not work, pull the head and see if you can tell if the head is warped or you just need a new head gasket. That's another $10 for a head gasket. If it's warped you can get it planed for $30. Why pay a wrench for something that I assure you, you can do and maybe save yourself a whole bunch of $? And more importantly learn something about your engine.
 
Top