Re: Evinrude 235 tried everything, no luck
From what you describe, I think it is a carburator issue. All the plugs should look the same. I would pull the carbs off and clean them.
If you are going to hook up an external tank, throw in some seafoam, that stuff works great, and might clean thinks up.
Other than that, I would check for spark output, these engines run like crap if the ignition system is not putting out full spark.
Is this the 235 that was for sale on Craigslist in the treasure coast area ?