Brand new starter worked once, then died.

kjempe

Recruit
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
5
I've got a 1990 Evinrude v4 90 hp vro motor. Here's the problem, after installing a brand new starter it worked for about 3 tries and then died. It turned the flywheel fine though the motor never turned over and ran. I engaged the starter 3 times, waiting good time in between and then just heard that click from the solenoid. I took the starter out of the motor and tried to test it to a fully charger battery and it does nothing, not even spin a little. Here is the history of the problems over the season.

Early in the season my original starter died. I knew this because I took it out and tested it. I got a new battery, and a used starter from another evinrude. I cleaned just every wire and connection and installed it. I also did the seafoam cleaning as directed from a post on this website. I checked the compression and all four cyl. were at 115-120. The boat started up and ran great for one trip. On the second trip after trying to start the boat, I melted the negative terminal on the battery. Don't know why that happened but got a different battery and it didn't happen again. Then the second used starter died. I know this because it wouldn't do anything when hooked up to a battery.

So this brings us to today. I ordered a brand new starter, new solenoid, and installed everything a couple hours ago. Cleaned all connections again and made sure the battery was fully charged. Spark plugs looked good and I tried to start the boat. Not sure why the starter would completely die after only 3 tries. I bought a volt tester and I'm getting 12v everywhere.

I've read about hydrolock but it doesn't look like there is any water in the cyl. Would hydrolock kill a starter that fast? Could a short somewhere kill a starter that fast?

Please help I don't want to have to buy a third starter to only have it die again...
 

kjempe

Recruit
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
5
Re: Brand new starter worked once, then died.

Ran all those tests and everything checked okay. Of course other than the bad starter... Does anyone know if there is something else that could cause a starter to fry like this after trying to start it 3 times?
 
Top