Re: Replaced water pump, now stuck in forward
Gary, I expect he's probably using a rubber strap, wrapped around the lower unit, to apply upwards pressure while he's up there moving the flywheel. A novel approach and might be something for the Ol' Bag of Tricks!
And yeah, the "free range" of the shift shaft when the gearbox is in Fwd can usually be achieved by rotating the shaft with your finger pressure only.
However, unless you have the proverbial Fingers Like Vise Grips, you're gonna need a bit more 'help' to move that shift shaft when you get it to the point where it's actually gonna shift some gears. Thus the pliers cushioned with a shop rag or equivalent, to keep the splines on the shift shaft un-marred.
Cheers.........ed