Re: 1958 Fastwin 18HP
Some people mistakenly think that TC-W3 oil is for a mix ratio of 50:1 and even call it "50:1 oil".
It is merely the third generation of oil specifically produced for water cooled, 2 stroke engines.
Two
Cycle-
Watercooled, version
3.
It should be used in a ratio specified by the outboard maker for TC-W oil.
OMC specified, in 1964, that all OMC outboards made before 1964 should use a 24:1 mix and all afterward should use a 50:1 (really 48:1) mix using TC-W outboard oil.
I think they were trying to simplify things but caused confusion instead. There is the idea that a 50:1 mix should only be used in engines with all ball and needle bearings and 24:1 in any engines that weren't all ball and needle bearings.
Why should two engines, one a '63 and one a '64, that are essentially identical, use mixes differing by 100%?
Ooops! That is where the arguments start.
JW (3HP) series engines continued to use sleeve bearings for another 6-7 years and FD (18HP) series engines had been using needle bearings already for some time.
Others contend that the change was because the TC-W oil was so far superior to SAE30 Non-detergent motor oil previously used. That is where the myth about "50:1 oil" came from. When you think about it, though, that doesn't make sense. They didn't say to continue to use the inferior oil at 24:1 in the older engines. They said to use TC-W oil in all of them. . .even in some older ones previously specified at 20:1 and 16:1 for the SAE30.
So, what do you do? I had a FD-16 (1962) 18HP that might have been safely run with 50:1 but I stuck with 24:1 because there just might have been some secret difference that OMC didn't tell about.
I also had a JW-21 (1966) (3HP) that I ran with 24:1 because it had sleeve bearings and 40 years ago I thought OMC made an error in re-specifying it to 50:1. If I had that little sweetheart today I would probably run her at 50:1.
I think that is about all I know (or can think of at this time) about that debate. If it helps you decide what to do, good. If not, well, I tried.
