Re: Evinrude 9.5 hp water pump
The water intakes on the 9.5 are the primary, which is the cylindrical screen below the A/V plate and just above the propeller, and the secondary, which is the rectangular piece with four holes just above the A/V plate. The primary intake is 4" below the bottom of the water pump impeller and the secondary is 3" below the bottom of the impeller. You need to cover the waterpump so that it will prime when running in a bucket.
When you run the 9.5 in the lake in gear, the propeller forces water into the primary intake; you don't have that luxury in a bucket.
You may well need a new impeller, but if you put a new one in and don't prime the pump, you will still need a new one.