What's the real story here?

oops!

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Oct 18, 2007
Messages
12,932
Re: What's the real story here?

a couple of things here.....

they are after the guy...not the boats.

the cause of the accident was overlaoding....that boat is the same design as the centurion....they are rated for 8 people.

the boat flipped because of wake or over loading....that is capitain error.

foam.....ok....that boat is 20 years old....it has water logged foam....that is because the owner didnt take care of the boat.....and let the elements get in there.

open cell vs closed cell.....in the 90's most were open cell....it has only been for the last 15 years that we have really been using closed cell....but even closed cell will waterlog.

as far as the owner being told to use closed cell.....yeah...i wouldnt doubt it...but the laws dont specify that you have to use closed....they just say foam or flotation........hell pool noodles will do. but the builder ...like most builders....will use what ever is cheapest. they need to do that to make the price point of the boat....each penny counts.
a smaller builder like that was producing tournament boats at a time when those boats were just breaking into the market.....and you could probably buy one whole sale around 19k...25-30 on the market.
for a builder to make those margins...he needs to do it cheap....each unit off the line....if he can save 10 bucks.....well thats a lot.

the big use for foam became apperant when builders realized that the glass is really strong and does not break down ....thats when they started to use the foam for struictural componants of the hull...

heck i hope they play that story to death....ill drive to wash state and buy up every one of those boats for a song....if people really want....ill re foam them....and sell them for 17k a pop !
 

Lion hunter

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Apr 9, 2005
Messages
1,529
Re: What's the real story here?

Water logged foam? Sounds like every boat in the restoration forum. We may all have a case against every boat manufacturer out there.

In all seriousness the builder does not seem to have a good track record and probably requires an investigation. But if the boat that sank is the same one as in the video it doesn't look rated for 9 people. And another justification for PFD's. I always liken PFD's to seat belts. It's your choice to wear them or not and everyone know it's a good idea to wear them. But I know that I always don't. But it is always close at hand. But if I drown with no PFD on it's no ones fault but my own regardless of how big a piece the boat is.
 

wwcj101

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Jun 20, 2009
Messages
44
Re: What's the real story here?

thanks for bringing this story. i want to do some follow up on it.
 

HappierWet

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Sep 11, 2008
Messages
839
Re: What's the real story here?

Start watching CL in the Pacific Northwest.:D:D
 

Cptkid570

Ensign
Joined
Oct 18, 2005
Messages
967
Re: What's the real story here?

How did that lady not make it out? They didn't have a collision or anything that would've resulted in her being knocked unconcious did they? Maybe she got caught up under all of the other people and drowned??
 

LIQUID PROZAC

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 19, 2009
Messages
307
Re: What's the real story here?

10 people on board:eek: and could you explain one more time why it capsized:confused:
 
Top