I/O VS Outboard

Billfo

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 12, 2009
Messages
189
Decisions decisions.... Looking to buy a used Lund 1850 Tyee. I am finding good deals on them with an outboard (that I am familiar with) and Mercruiser 3.1L (which I have no idea about).. I know it maybe personal preference, but is there an advantage of one over the other ?
*I live in Nebraska where the winters are harsh, but boat will be stored in the attached garage.
Thanks, (and be kind) :redface: Billfo
 

Billfo

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 12, 2009
Messages
189
Re: I/O VS Outboard

This is a link to the "latest" discussion.

Thank you very much.. That kind of answers my questions..One thing is winterizing is easier on an outboard, I read instructions for the I/O & honestly... " too much work for me" LOL.. Just spoke with dealer svce dept, advised me of $250 winterizing cost.. ( im ok with that) but mentioned on a 1995 Tyee, i should be concerned with the rubber & bellows kit ( says this would be a 1400 maint job) YIPES !
Not pleased with THAT turn of events...

Thanks again for the link.. So much to read & learn HUGE FAQ section here ! Bill
 

Pierutrus

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Mar 25, 2007
Messages
721
Re: I/O VS Outboard

Nope, Bellows about $600, with the shift cable, need to do it about every 5-6 years. And you will see it coming. Winterizing, about another $299.OO.
And that's in Vegas.;)
 

DavidInWilmNC

Seaman
Joined
Jul 20, 2009
Messages
50
Re: I/O VS Outboard

I winterized my I/O (a '74 Century with a Merc. 888) for the 7 years that I had it. I would not pay even $100 for somebody to do that. I read the flyer from the shop where I had the boat serviced and did everything it mentioned myself plus anything else in the manual. I had bellows, shift cables, and gimbal bearing replaced once. I think the total for all that was around $650. I do think an outboard can be somewhat easier to own, in terms of maintenance, but a lot of this is due to the fact that we boat in salt water. I'll also add that my V8 powered 21' I/O was quieter and used a lot less fuel than my 17' with a 90hp 2-stroke outboard.
 

DavidInWilmNC

Seaman
Joined
Jul 20, 2009
Messages
50
Re: I/O VS Outboard

Well, sorta...don't forget the cost of the fogging oil...so less than $10.

That's what I spent to winterie my I/O... plus a small amount of antifreeze.

I used to hook a 6' hose to the muffs and put 'em on the drive. I had a big funnel stuck in the end of the hose. I put half of a gallon of antifreeze in an empty antifreeze jug that I had and filled 'em both with water to give two gallons of 50-50 mix. I'd fill the hose and funnel with the mixture and crank and run the engine while continually filling the funnel. I did this until the antifreeze came out of the exhaust. Granted, I live in NC where it's not all that cold. We do have a few cold days and nights a year when it's down in the 20's. The boat was stored on the north side of a shed in the shade, so it really never got warm on those days. Besides preventing freezing, antifreeze is a rust inhibitor, which has got to be good for those manifolds and risers. It wasn't much trouble to do this, but I don't know that I'd want to do it more than once a winter if I used the boat during cold weather!

Another plus, to me, is that the single carb. on an I/O is a lot cheaper to rebuild or replace than the multiple carbs on most outboards. That old Holley 2-bbl was easy to drain and seemed to be a bit more tolerant to ethanol and moisture in fuel. I don't know if this experience is universal or not.
 
Top