Re: 15 hp 4 stroke
over-revving, while bad, isn't as damaging as lugging, by a far cry...
you may be a candidate for a vented prop... I've made like four posts here, including this one, and each of them spoke of using vented props... I reckon I'm more of a fan of that than I realized?
it's been my observation, for what it's worth, that small boats are more about the differences in load on the boat, while larger boats are more about the boat... I'd guess it a game with percentages of weight- a smaller boat like yours, with one extra passenger, raised it's displacement in percentages much more than a larger boat would have with the same passenger would have.. it pays to have a versatile prop in that circumstance, or two props to use depending on what you're doing..
If I were you, I'd try a 11p vented prop, or a 10p non-vented, but slightly larger in diameter. moving to a four blade, I'd use a 10p vented or not...
If you choose to use a 10p four blade vented, (which I think will suit your needs) make sure and keep similar diameter, and have one with an aggressive 'progressive pitch', which would make the 'average' pitch 10p, but the leading edge around 8.5p and the trailing edge around 11.5p, and with a decent cup. This will allow you to rev faster (vents), punch the bow out of the hole (water off leading edge- shallower pitch of the blade), and lift the stern as it bites in (water forcing off of trailing edge of higher pitch).. the cup will allow better bite in turns.