Re: 1956 Johnson Seahorse 5 1/2 Part Numbers
If you want the complete water pump kit, which is now made of plastic with stainless steel liners (far better than the old aluminum housing):
The complete plastic kit is 391391 superceded by 763758
The impeller for that is 387361 superceded by 763735
You will think they sent you the wrong pump, but it will fit and work very well.