Re: 1987 vip vindicator 2250 prop ?
It would depend on the drive unit you have.
Again, you really need to take it to a dealer for assistance with this issue. Your altitude and the way you load out your boat will make a big difference.
Aluminum vs Stainless, the jury is still out on that. Theoretically, they should be so close as it would be non-issue, provided both props had the same size and shape to the cups.
And personally, I think that may be the reason why stainless has generally out-performed aluminum. To increase cup strength, they put more curve in the cups (and thicker) on aluminum. Where-as stainless, had a more "slip through" profile that allowed more efficiency. Mostly on top end and cruise. A prop that has best efficiency for top end usually has the worst for hole shot and vis-versa.