Re: 2000 Johnson 90hp tach
SS It sounds like you have the "System Check" Tach. If you have the 60 degree v-4 engine, there is a somewhat complex procedure for testing the tach circuits. In summary, the purple wire needs to have +12V, when the key is on, the black wire is ground, and the tach wire is the grey one. The tricky part is that both the purple and grey wires also go to the VRO pump on the motor, for some unknown purpose.
Even with the OEM Service manual, I was unable to determine if the voltage regulator on the motor was shot (BTW it charges pretty well), or the tach was broken. I plan to replace the tach and see what happens. If you look on the net, the System Check Tach can be had in the Faria Chesapeake White SS version for $99 plus shipping.