I'm no expert, but I've been researching props myself... given the other chatter taking place, perhaps a new prop isn't what you need, but here is what I've learned about 3 vs. 4 blade props:
When going from a 3 blade to a 4 blade you generally drop 2" in pitch to achieve the same WOT RPM. I'm sure there are exceptions to the rule, but that would be per the prop manufacturer. You will likely lose some top end speed at the same RPM. The trade off is better holeshot performance - across the board when I've read reviews on such a swap the holeshot performance is night & day.
If you are going from stainless to aluminum, or vice-versa, pitch behaves differently as well (aluminum flexes more), so you generally need more pitch in an aluminum prop to equate a stainless one. Again, I'm sure there are exceptions. The prop manufacturer is probably the best source.
Generally speaking, the 4 blade will give you more stern lift, thus helping you plane faster. It seems that the solution to better holeshot is almost always to go to a 4 blade if you're running a 3 blade. The high-five merc prop is something to consider as well. The reviews are pretty positive when discussing holeshot and control, but it is a smaller diameter prop, and has too much slip on heavier boats; so, it doesn't work for me (my boat weighs 4500lbs dry). It might work for you though.