3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

Zer0

Cadet
Joined
Mar 30, 2008
Messages
11
I know 3M 5200 is a great product but is there anything equivelent to it out there? I bought 1 tube at West Marine (10 oz.) for under $10 on a heck of a sale they had a few weeks ago. No, I'm not smart enough to buy more than one. Sale will prob. never happen again. Heard Home Depot use to sell it for $11 or so not long back but it's discontinued now. Thanks for the tips, Great boating forum!!!!!
 

tashasdaddy

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Nov 11, 2005
Messages
51,019
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

sorry. try lowes.
 

drewmitch44

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Jun 26, 2005
Messages
1,749
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

I dont think Blows has it eather. Pl poly construction adheasive is like the 5200 though. Its not semi-removeable like the 4200 is but it will work and its not as expencive. It is sold at Blows and home cheapo.
 

fixb52s

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 14, 2004
Messages
463
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

I seen it at Wal Mart for around $10.50 a few months ago.​
 

WizeOne

Commander
Joined
Mar 23, 2008
Messages
2,097
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

Just bought a 10 oz tube at Casa del Cheapo yesterday. It was $6.57. I also bought a caulking gun size tube of PL Premium for 4.97.

I bought the 5200, as an experiment to patch some 3/16" holes in the side of a steel building. (no backing) So far, after a day, I think the Vulkem 116 does a better job of that.

24+ hours later, the 5200 was very rubbery and did not slice, off the surface, cleanly.
 

Robj

Lieutenant
Joined
Mar 22, 2007
Messages
1,441
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

Sikaflex is similiar to 5200, just as good IMO, but generally cheaper. Save the construction adhesive for the construction site, not for keeping water out of a boat.

Have a great day,

Rob.
 

erikgreen

Captain
Joined
Jan 8, 2007
Messages
3,105
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

If you read the ingredients, the crack and masonry sealer is a pretty good match to 3m 5200, except a different color. It's a good sealant, and I can also vouch for it as an assembly glue, but for that need the PL premium works better I think.

Home depot and Lowes still sell 5200, they should be able to get you a case of it or more.

However, the C+M sealant is a decent substitute, and I think Vulkem would work ok too. But do you really need to save $3 that badly?

Erik
 

wca_tim

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
May 28, 2007
Messages
1,708
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

no reason that pl polyurethane construction adhesive won't hold up nearly indefinately in water... I just used it to lay the stringers in my boat and to hold the deck down... I used epoxy and glass over it on all the stringers and other joints i faired with it. It does bubble (releasing co2 as isocyanate reactions with moisture) a little and as noted above the bubbling sems to be more pronounced the more you mess with it.

I used it to seal something temporarily, no way I'm going nto tell you what, and am leaving it for the time being s an experiment...

In short, I wouldn't hesitate to use it for most things... but would pay the extra coin for the 3m product if it were external seal for wod against water...
 

marquette

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Apr 18, 2006
Messages
372
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

hi
has anyone tried the PL Ultimate Sealer and Adhesive? their web site says it is new. i bought a tube of it at lowes and used it this weekend to seal around some bolts. it seemed to stick really well to fiberglass and when it cured it felt somewhere between the PL construction adhesive and a silicone sealant. much tougher than silicone but not as hard cured PL constuction adhesive. it's $9 a tube so not a huge savings over 5200 but much more readily available to me. i didn't try it on any plastic or painted surfaces to see how it reacted.
 

Squid Billy

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Jun 3, 2008
Messages
152
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

I used it to seal something temporarily, no way I'm going nto tell you what, and am leaving it for the time being s an experiment...

Let me quess;

1). Fuel Tank
2). Porta Potty
3). Cooling System
4). Trailer Tire

Awwww Come on ...... Tell us ........ :confused: :p
 

reelfishin

Captain
Joined
Mar 19, 2007
Messages
3,050
Re: 3M 5200 - Any equals for less $ ????

Years ago I trash picked an old aluminum 10' V hull row boat, it had been dropped on the highway and abandoned and had one lower rear corner of the stern smashed in and ground away leaving about an inch wide opening about 10" long. Not having any means to weld or properly repair this with, I used the first super adhesive that I was familiar with. I hammered the opening closed to form two parallel edges, cut and shaped a piece of wood to fit into the lower transom to bottom seam, and sealled it with automotive windshield urethane prior to bolting in the wood brace. I then coated the entire repair and all seams in the area with the same sealer. It wasn't pretty but it was water proof. I only used that boat for dock maintenance since it let me get up around and under the docks and pilings on the lake, but it lasted at least 8 years, and is most likely still being used today. The total cost of the repair was about $4 at the time and one trash picked table leg which I used for the wood filler.
If you ever tried to remove a car windshield or the sealer from the glass or metal, you know what stuff I am talking about. It also takes paint well.

At the time, I had never heard of 4200 or 5200, and was no way spending the money on getting it welded. I can only picture what it would take to remove that stuff if someone ever wanted to do a proper fix on that boat. These days there are epoxies and all sorts of adhesives to choose from but 15 years ago, the automotive windshield urethane was the best I could come up with and it worked great. (It wasn't the prettiest repair, the stuff is a shiny black color that looks about like black RTV when dry).
 
Top