a good debate

Whaler Proud

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Feb 23, 2003
Messages
187
Re: a good debate

I am new to this forum and am very impressed with the content, and this thread in particular.<br /><br />All of your statements and opinions are evidence of why the government system we operate under is the best. Our government can be changed at will, by the people. This is what our founding fathers intended, even by force if need be (sorry gun-control guys). Any of us have the ability to work within the system and change it.<br /><br />Before I am flamed out of here :>), let me say that every single point of view posted is valid. But the freedom to disagree is what makes our system work. Our country was settled by people from different nations, cultures, languages that all had to somehow retain their identity but still work together. It has not been easy and was most certainly not fair at all times, but it continues on.<br /><br />For 400 years people have been trying to get to America. And today people are still trying to get to America, and until people begin voting with their feet and leave America, I would have to presume that our form of government is best, bar none.<br /><br />Just my humble .02<br /><br />WP
 

moderator1

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Dec 5, 2002
Messages
1,668
Re: a good debate

Whaler Proud,<br /><br />Welcome aboard!<br /><br />You will not have to worry about being banned unless you make a personal attack on one or more members of this forum.<br /><br />Otherwise, opinions are welcome here.
 

SpinnerBait_Nut

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Aug 25, 2002
Messages
17,651
Re: a good debate

Ahoy whaler proud and welcome to our forums.<br />Your opinion is just that, your's and everyone has their own.<br />You will be in good shape here as long as you do no name calling and the like.<br />The powers at be are pretty liberal as long as it is "tame" so to speak, so jump right in with both feet anytime you feel like it.<br />You will find out if you stay long enough that there are some very smart and helpful people on these forums that can answer about anything you need to know from computers to recipes.<br />Again, welcome aboard. :)
 

Whaler Proud

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Feb 23, 2003
Messages
187
Re: a good debate

Thanks gentlemen. I'll probably hang low and take advantage of all the experience here before posting too much. Of course political threads may prove too tempting.<br /><br />Great site!
 

miloman

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Nov 3, 2002
Messages
1,181
Re: a good debate

I believe that every point has validity. That being said as free men we are all alowed to our opinions it was said<br /><br />If it truely is your thought that we are all in a state of Anarchy why would you not be armed? <br /><br />(I have faith in god that as a moral man I choose to associate with other moral men hence my lack of need)<br />Or is it in actuality that you readily dismiss an admitted near perfect form of government while hoping for a better one around the corner? <br /><br />No not al all I believe in government as a whole without it there would be no education social servies etc.. it is the corruption and greed I dis agree with!<br /><br />If you couldn't help in preserving the near perfect one why would you do better with the next one? I am but 1 man <br /><br />Since you say elimination of GREED will be our salvation, common sense should tell you it won't be clubs and pitchforks that will eliminate the greed, corruption and evil. are you stating that guns will that is like saying pick up my gun and shoot some one when in fact you should be wanting to educate propigate a position of betterment. Choose to work towards goals of personal fullfilment not based on financial reward<br /><br />You mentioned previously in reference to good or bad nieghbors. Certainly law abiding citizens who are armed, or not, with good moral characture and values are not an indication of being a bad nieghbor or friend.<br /><br /> I dont think that was the point if my neighbor was a moral honourable humble sole and he had a closet full of hand guns and assault rifles I would want to get as far away from him as possible because despite any opinion those are people killers and even with the information that (he is only protecting his family) MY QUESTION IS FROM WHAT AN INVASION FORCE<br /><br />I'm happy for you that as a Canadian you've found peace in your convictions on gun control. While your point of view is worthy for debate, I'd rather be part of a patriotic movement that will prove to be the line drawn in the sand against my government exceeding its powers against me as an AMERICAN CITIZEN. You can be rest assured that to maintain and preserve my right to bear arms that I conduct my affairs in all accordance with the law. Since I am permitted to carry concealed, I treat others with respect and I AVOID conflict with strict determination. What I consider inalienable right and duty to my family and country, you consider a flaw. <br /><br /> Im sorry you feel that way, is not the purpose on this planet the betterment of one self I provide the duty to my family equally by teaching them about god, morality, respect, honour, trust,law, to help others that need your help I dont want children to avoid a conflict simply for fear that the other party might have a conceled weapon and end the conflict by a bullet in the head.<br /><br />I'm seeing a pattern of a very cynical view. <br /><br />not at all my views are determind by the moral back bone of my family, church, and faith in a greater purpose. I believe America is a great country I have stated that fact all along but I believe the ability to have hugh collections of people killers will be the undoing of your moral and spiritial fabric and that is a shame because I dont believe that your forfathers wanted it that way.
 

SpinnerBait_Nut

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Aug 25, 2002
Messages
17,651
Re: a good debate

I'm gona throw my .02 worth in here and then I'm done with this one.<br />As far as gun control goes, it's alright if it would work, but if you want a gun, just go to the local flea markets and get one.<br />I for one carry a gun and am permited to do such because of the business I am in, but there are plenty out there that don't need any guns at all, and they are the one's that get them anyway they can.<br />Not all are bad people, but if you have to get one anywhere else but at a regular gun shop, then something is wrong.<br />I will agree that sometimes you can get a good deal on one, but you don't know where or what that gun has done in the past so beware.<br />This is not the way to solve crime as we have it today.<br />Education is the only way to cut down on it.<br />OK, I'm done.<br />Click_____________*************
 

miloman

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Nov 3, 2002
Messages
1,181
Re: a good debate

Spinner bait nut good point bye the way hows the smokes
 

Skinnywater

Commander
Joined
Mar 7, 2002
Messages
2,065
Re: a good debate

>I believe that every point has validity. That >being said as free men we are all alowed to our >opinions it was said<br /><br />Absolutely agreed.<br /><br />>>it truly is your thought that we are all in a >>state of Anarchy why would you not be armed? <br />>(I have faith in god that as a moral man I >choose to associate with other moral men hence >my lack of need)<br />> if my neighbor was a moral honourable humble >sole and he had a closet full of hand guns and >assault rifles I would want to get as far away >from him as possible because despite any opinion >those are people killers and even with the >information that (he is only protecting his >family)<br /><br />Both responses infer that you don't associate with people that have firearms and are afraid of firearms. The second response infers that a person can be morally correct yet still own a firearm. <br />Alright, that's how you feel. I accept this fact. I'll not try to tell you it's wrong or FLAWED. <br />Why would you not extend me the same courtesy? I have both state and federal laws on my side. I'm trained and tested on my legally owned and registered guns. I'm a fully functional and productive citizen that is involved in my community and am morally intact.<br />The fact you wouldn't break bread with me is irrelevant.<br /><br />>MY QUESTION IS FROM WHAT AN INVASION FORCE<br /><br />ANY INVASION FORCE, FOREIGN OR DOMESTIC. ANY EVIL/CRAZY/DRUGGED/BAD PERSON THAT WANT TO ME OR MINE HARM. <br />THE HORSE THAT IS IN AN OVERTURNED TRAILER AND HAS MULTIPLE COMPOUND FRACTURES. THE PITBULL THAT HAS AN OLD LADY ON THE GROUND. THE BELTWAY SNIPER THAT IS ABOUT TO PULL THE TRIGGER ON YOUR WIFE. THE LOCAL SHERIFF DEPUTY THAT IS BEING OVERPOWERED BY A DRUG CRAZED PURP. THE SKUNK THAT IS CHASING THE NEIGHBORS COW AROUND. <br /> <br /><br />>I believe in government as a whole without it >there would be no education social servies etc.. >it is the corruption and greed I dis agree with!<br /><br />I'll respect your Canadian view on government. Again, respect mine that I'm not happy with socialism. Corruption and greed is despicable.<br /><br />>>Since you say elimination of GREED will be our >>salvation, common sense should tell you it >>won't be clubs and pitchforks that will >>eliminate the greed, corruption and evil. <br />>are you stating that guns will? that is like >saying pick up my gun and shoot some one when in >fact you should be wanting to educate propigate >a position of betterment.<br /><br />Whoa! Hmmm. That is some pretty good talk after a few bowls of herb, but there are some real mean, nasty, no good people out there that could care less about you propagating a position of betterment. <br /><br />>> Choose to work towards goals of personal >>fulfillment not based on financial reward<br /><br />Miloman......dude.......just send me the links. Don't be quoting Dr. Lilyanna's self help advice for urban lifestyles on me now!<br /><br />> is not the purpose on this planet the >betterment of one self I provide the duty to my >family equally by teaching them about god, >morality,respect, honour, trust,law, to help >others that need your help I dont want children >to avoid a conflict simply for fear that the >other party might >have a conceled weapon and >end the conflict by a bullet in the head.<br /><br />Again, you should be teaching your children that there are evil people. It's truly flawed teaching them that anyone with or owning a gun is evil.<br />It's discomforting to know you're raising kids that will follow your lead by saying that I'm wrong or flawed because I legally own guns. <br />The chances of my guns harming you or yours is ABSOLUTELY NONE and you and your children have such a low opinion of me! <br />So much for your education in god, morality, respect, trust and law!<br /> <br /> >I believe America is a great country I have >stated that fact all along but I believe the >ability to have hugh collections of people >killers I dont >believe that your forfathers >wanted it that way.<br /><br />Read it and weep Miloman. The Constitution, The Federalist papers and EVERY written and spoken word of the founding fathers. Your way off here my man. Don't take my word for it just punch it in on the www. The founding fathers were very clear about who, what and why. <br />Your just wishing that what you just said is true.
 

miloman

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Nov 3, 2002
Messages
1,181
Re: a good debate

Both responses infer that you don't associate with people that have firearms and are afraid of firearms. The second response infers that a person can be morally correct yet still own a firearm. <br />Alright, that's how you feel. I accept this fact. I'll not try to tell you it's wrong or FLAWED. <br />Why would you not extend me the same courtesy? I have both state and federal laws on my side. I'm trained and tested on my legally owned and registered guns. I'm a fully functional and productive citizen that is involved in my community and am morally intact.<br />The fact you wouldn't break bread with me is irrelevant.<br /><br /> I dont believe that I made reference to that. Simply put I have no issues with a person who owns a hunting rifle nor a person who collects firearms but yet has no ammunition for those fire arms, people who collect people killers in my opinion are wrong regardless of their socioeconmic situation, as a good christian I wouls surly break bread with<br /><br /> Whoa! Hmmm. That is some pretty good talk after a few bowls of herb, but there are some real mean, nasty, no good people out there that could care less about you propagating a position of betterment. I believe that there is no need for charecter assault and as for this point.. that is why there are jails <br /><br />Again, you should be teaching your children that there are evil people. It's truly flawed teaching them that anyone with or owning a gun is evil.<br />It's discomforting to know you're raising kids that will follow your lead by saying that I'm wrong or flawed because I legally own guns. <br />The chances of my guns harming you or yours is ABSOLUTELY NONE and you and your children have such a low opinion of me! <br />So much for your education in god, morality, respect, trust and law!<br /><br />I dont believe I made reference to you I teach my children to respect all and again personal references to myself or my family make me question your ethics the fact you legally are allowed to possess weapons is your right, why the need for people killers in fact I tend to think that you are an educated man which leads me to the question again why do you possess people killers, what is it that you fear the man across the street<br /><br />Did the forfathers intend for you to own people killers did your for fathers intend for you to avoid conflict for fear that the other person has a concelled weapon I dont think so I believe that you are blinded by this fact was it not the intent of the forfathers to give you the right to bear arms to protect yourself from fiend or government, then why such a nagative view of malitia Had the forfathers been present in todays society Im sure that that ammendment would be very different<br /><br />I respect a hunter who owns a gun for the purpose of hunting or a person who enjoys collecting firearms for the sole purpose of collecting what I dont understand is the person who carries a conceled weapon or a stash of people killers in his basement. I dont make reference to them being morally wrong I think you should understand what my position is re this matter prior to comment I do believe that your government must rewrite the laws to such a degree that we as law abiding citizens ( your self included Im sure) dont have to be concerned that as I go to work in the morning a sniper or disgruntled employee will kill me or anyone else I believe it to be fact that countries with stricter gun control as a whole have less crime and murder Although you do make valid points I believe you to be blinded by your god given right I wont comment on any personal assaults regarding this matter you have your opinion and I have mine This post was designed to have a dialogue about government and certainly not a discussion of the right to bear arms As the moral man you say you are how would you feel if your neighbor co worker friend or family was gunned down by a crazed person who also believed in his god given right Im sure your opinion would change. Enough of this post I hope JB will close it
 

dkondelik

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Sep 10, 2002
Messages
643
Re: a good debate

Take a Breath Plywoody,<br /><br />Yup! this was to be a debate on the best form of government. After "Beating-the-Dead-Horse", and finally coming to the unanimous conclusion, I, your newly appointed KING will offer the following per 2 of your previous posts.<br /><br />1. The Indiana Cop with his gun near by. The cops that I know frequently answer their front door with a pistol in possession. WHY? BAD GUYS know where they live AND have been known - not to call in advance to announce their intentions.<br /><br />2. A disarmed society IS NOT SAFER as only the BAD GUYS are armed. You cannot honestly believe that when the new gun laws are enacted that, the BAD GUYS get in line to "register" or "turn-in" their newly outlawed fire-arms. Look at both England and Australia. The stats may be a bit difficult to compile (political reasons) but,... believe that enough evidence is in to show that INDEED, the criminals feel safer when "Breaking & Entering" knowing that the VICTOM cannot defend himself. wucha-gunna-do? Call 911? (You might want to ask a cop about 911 response times. I lived it before I re-armed and moved)<br /><br />Maybe we just agree to dis agree. <br /><br />Take heart knowing that if you're ever in my neck of the woods, you'll be safe. Perps are wary to venture here as the word is out. We don't tolerate their stuff.
 

Skinnywater

Commander
Joined
Mar 7, 2002
Messages
2,065
Re: a good debate

> fire arms, people who collect people killers in >my opinion are wrong regardless of their >socioeconmic situation, <br /><br />In your opinion I'm wrong. That is fine with me Miloman. It's fine with me even if it's based on fear, emotion, or any other reason. <br />However, you started this thread and it was a political one. You also were the one that changed the course of the topic and introduced gun control. You started this debate and I'm participating with you. The major point is that I'm not meddling into your lifestyle by voicing an opinion on it. I especially wouldn't if it was based on fear/emotion or misrepresenting the facts.<br /><br />You keep mentioning "peoplekillers." A gun is a piece of metal and wood/plastic, it is like a stone, or a stick, or a hubcap on a car.<br />Cain didn't slay Able with a gun and David didn't slay Goliath with a "peoplekiller"<br /><br />>as a good Christian I wouls surly break bread with<br />>>if my neighbor was a moral honorable humble sole and he had a closet full of hand guns and assault rifles I would want to get as far >>away from him as possible<br /><br />OK, you might be able to see where I'd be confused. :confused: I only pointed out that a good Christian would break bread. Your previous statement infers prejudice. <br /><br />>I dont believe I made reference to you I teach my children to respect all and again personal references to myself or my family make me >question your ethics the fact you legally are allowed to possess weapons is your right.<br /><br />Again, this confuses me because the issue was your opinion on people who own guns. I own many that you consider "peoplekillers". Logically I'd understand that you made reference to me. <br />In all fairness we both made personal references to our families/children in the course of discussion. I'm sorry if you felt I was disrespecting them/you. Sincerely it wasn't my intention.<br />However, I feel I've made headway since you've acknowledged my right to possess legal firearms.<br /><br />>why the need for people killers in fact I tend to think that you are an educated man which leads me to the question again why do you >possess people killers<br /><br />I've given you SEVERAL reasons in SEVERAL posts why. Even though I've given you SEVERAL reasons You're unwilling to accept ANY as legitimate. <br />Here is one more answer to your question and I'll make it harsh to drive it home to you. Since I choose to legally own and exercise my Constitutional right and it doesn't have an adverse effect on you or yours, it isn't any of your business why. It should be a complete NON issue to you.<br /><br />> what is it that you fear the man across the street<br /><br />I went over this in my previous post. Again, your not accepting what I'm saying as sincere, honest beliefs. :rolleyes: <br /><br />>Did the forefathers intend for you to own people killers.<br /><br />Absolutely! <br />Thats affirmative! <br />Yes, without a doubt!<br />Just because you don't accept it, doesn't mean it isn't true.<br /><br />> did your for fathers intend for you to avoid conflict for fear that the other person has a concealed weapon<br /><br />You don't know, that you don't know. <br />Two strange men meet in the woods, both assume the other is armed, here is the MOST respectful, cordial, polite men you'll ever meet! I've personally witnessed it time and time again.<br />Morally correct, free men are generally respectful.<br /><br />> I dont think so I believe that you are blinded by this fact was it not the intent of the forfathers to give you the right to bear arms to protect >yourself from fiend or government, then why such a negative view of malitia Had the forfathers been present in todays society Im sure >that that ammendment would be very different<br /><br />Your pulling old Skinnys leg aren't you?<br />Please Miloman, next time think twice about starting a political thread. Think three times before you start a political/hotbed debate. Think four times before you start using language like flawed and wrong before you talk about a mans Constitution, lifestyle and freedom. :rolleyes: <br /><br />>I do believe that your government must rewrite the laws to such a degree that we as law abiding citizens ( your self included Im sure) dont >have to be concerned that as I go to work in the morning a sniper or disgruntled employee will kill me or anyone else <br /><br />We need to enforce the laws we already have. Miloman, I'm NOT concerned that I'll get killed by a gunman on my way to work in the morning. I'm WAY WAY more concerned I'll get killed by a road rageing young woman who had an arguement with her hubby earlier that morning. Or that businessman who is talking golf on his cellphone during the commute. Or the housewife in the Excursion that is yelling at the kids at 82 MPH. Or the 76 year old man that is entering Interstate5 at 41mph and can't turn his arthitic head around to check his blindspot. <br /><br />>I believe it to be fact that countries with stricter gun control as a whole have less crime and murder <br /><br />I don't even want to be a Canadian :p , or Chinese, or Russian, Israeli, Brit, French, Iraqi.<br /> I'm American, a hardworker, a freeman, a lover and a fighter, don't try to talk me into something less, PLEASE!<br /><br /> >I believe you to be blinded by your god given right<br /><br />God doesn't blind us. He shows us the light so we can see, Miloman. <br /><br /> >As the moral man you say you are how would you feel if your neighbor co worker friend or family was gunned down by a crazed person >who also believed in his god given right Im sure your opinion would change.<br /><br />Maybe so, but then my view would be based on emotion instead of common sense, fact and logic. I'm sure I wouldn't emotionally debate gun control on the www after such a tragedy.<br /><br />>Enough of this post I hope JB will close it.<br /><br />Miloman, you can stop this anytime you want. I've only posted to you as a rebuttal. <br />Again, my apologies if I've seemed harsh. I've not meant any disrespect to you, your views or feelings. Thank you for your participation and for the entertainment this has provided.<br />God bless and peace to you and yours Miloman. ;)
 

rudeafrican

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Oct 29, 2002
Messages
225
Re: a good debate

Miloman<br /><br />I feel obliged to jump in and correct a simple statement thrown about as fact in your post.<br /><br />>"I believe it to be fact that countries with stricter gun control as a whole have less crime and murder "<br /><br />Do a bit of research on crime and murder and you will find that South Africa has the highest murder and armed crime rate per capita in the world. To date this year alone, over 4000 cases of car hijacking has been reported. These are ALWAYS carried out by armed criminals who do not hesitate to shoot. And my point here is that we have one of the strictest gun control laws around. Other than totally disarming citizens, the laws restrict citizens to only 1 firearm per household, all firearms are registered, the owner of the firearm must hold a license for the firearm which he/she only gets after completing a firearm instruction course, police inspection of premises where firearm is to be kept to ensure proper storage facilities exist (safe).<br /><br />These are just some of the laws we have and yet our crime rate is so high. Further investigation reveals that over 80% of the crimes committed were with illegal and unlicensed firearms and a further 16% with stolen firearms.<br /><br />So next time when trying to pass off some of your wishful thinking as fact, please do a bit of research.<br /><br />As to the form of government of the USA, that is the reason why I have already applied for permanent residence status for myself and my family, makes you think doesn't it....
 

SpinnerBait_Nut

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Aug 25, 2002
Messages
17,651
Re: a good debate

Man I know that there should be a bunch of flags thrown here, but don't know where to start.
mouse2.gif
mouse2.gif
mouse2.gif
mouse2.gif
 

miloman

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Nov 3, 2002
Messages
1,181
Re: a good debate

I agree we argree to diagree lets leave it at that Hope to see you on a ramp some day and have a cold one and exchange fishing stories ok skinny water I mean this is a topic we could discuss for weeks the fact is we grew up in different countries with different views on this topic, and regardless of our beliefs we are products of our environment stay healthy as for south africa well that is a whole other issue
 
Top