Re: are these parts compatible?
What you see before you (on the V4) is typical coking damage. The rings carbon up (coking) and stick in the ring land on the backside oppsite the end gap. As more and more of the ring sticks in, the piston loses support and rocks in the bore. Eventually the pistons rocks enough that the end of the ring shears off.<br /><br />If you hold the piston so the dome is up, I'll bet the ring broke on the right side of the locating pin first. And this happens on the starboard side cylinders first too.<br /><br />This is typical of a "lugged" or "overpropped" (terrible phrase but common) motor. On the V4 and V6 crossflow this happens sooner if the motor is set up so that wide open is at or near 5000 rpm. IE -- if the top rpm is 5000 this will happen relatively quickly. Sometimes in 25 running hours. If the top rpm is around 5500, it will take longer. Possibly twice as long. If its set up at or near 6000 rpm it will rarely happen.<br /><br />Good decarb jobs will definately help avoid this. Good decarbs and good set up will avoid this alltogether.<br /><br />Good luck!