Re: boating license
As regards to "safe boating," I think the requirement of a license of sorts is a good one! In Vermont, anyone born after 1974 is required to take the Safe Boating course to operate a boat legally (as a Vermont resident). At the very least, it
may save a life or two to have a newbie hear boat and water safety at least once.
At the same time, an extraordinarily large number of boating accidents which involve injury or death are alcohol related. So I know that the stupid-human-factor reaches beyond mere education. Like the older man a few years ago here in Vermont: alcohol involved, had 11 people on a small sailboat. It capsized; two young children (brother and sister) died. Tragic.
Then there are those who, sober, could use a safety course, even if born before 1974. I know a man personally who had 5 people in a 12' tinny last summer and was swamped by a ski boat wake. Fortunately no injuries, but the boat had no flotation and sunk, and was lost.
In Vermont, there are also laws which require life jackets all the time while on board for children up to 12 years, and life jackets while underway (but not while anchored) up to age 16, as well as other restrictions.
DJ said: "
I'm not sure which way I would go on this one.
Motor Vehicle drivers licenses do not seem have any effect on getting bad drivers off of the road. Here in AZ, upwards of 25% of the drivers here do not have one."
Wow. That scares me a little. The only ones I hear about in Vermont who drive without licenses are "DLS" - Drivers License Suspended, usually due to DUI or multiple infractions (again, usually including DUI).
I wonder what the statistic is here?
One last thing- requiring the Safe Boating thing is handy. I don't have to say "no" to most of the people who ask to operate my boat

I just ask, "Do you have the Vermont Safe Boating certificate?" They say "no," I purse my lips, they turn away- end of conversation!