Choice of Two Boats - What Would You Do?

thompsdw

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Dec 27, 2002
Messages
75
My brain is about smoked on this one and I need the advice of the boating bretheren. I am looking at 2 boats: a 2001 SeaRay Sundeck 210 ($25,000) and a Smokercraft Commander 2080 ($19,400). Here are some links to the spec sheets on the boats:<br /><br /> http://www.smokercraft.com/2003/fiberglass/commander2080iore.htm <br /><br /> http://www.searay.com/Boat_Graphics/Sea_Ray_Archives/owners_manuals/210_Sundeck/210_Sundeck.pdf <br /><br />Both have the features that we are looking for in a boat, however, the Smokercraft has a 5.0L MPI with 2 years of warranty and the Searay has a 5.0L with EFI with no warranty. The Smokercraft is lighter and faster. The Searay heavier with more deadrise is better in the chop. Either boat price is without trailer so that I can find one that will allow me to fit the boat in the garage. What do you guys/gals think?????
 

Spidybot

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Apr 4, 2002
Messages
1,734
Re: Choice of Two Boats - What Would You Do?

I can't make up your mind, but for what it's worth I can say, that my 6th boat is a Sea Ray and I'm very pleased with it. It is facing it's 13th season now and it never missed a beat.<br /><br />As with all, proper care and maintenance is crucial. Regardless of brand, your servicing it while not in use is the base for it servicing you while in use.<br /><br />That said, the weight should be considered. Although a lighter boat will have a better power/weight ratio, the heavier boat may be better value in terms of material thicknes, strength etc.<br /><br />Smoker has been in business since 1961 and as such is very experienced. It's a family-run operation. Sea-Ray, also an oldie in this industry, is part of a huge corporation and build a very large number of boats. The family of brands include several well known, aimed at different customer segments - and Sea Ray is one of the top brands.<br /><br />
The Boat Group makes Sea Ray, Bayliner, Maxum, Hatteras, Meridian and Sealine pleasure boats from 16 to 100 feet; Baja high-performance boats from 20 to 44 feet; Boston Whaler and Trophy offshore fishing boats from 13 to 32 feet; and Princecraft fishing, deck and pontoon boats from 12 to 26 feet. Land ‘N’ Sea, marine parts and accessories distribution and Attwood marine parts manufacturer, are also part of the Brunswick Boat Group
More on http://www.brunswick.com/boats.html. <br /><br />Company size is absolutely no guarantee for quality (very scary story) but should be included in your considerations.<br /><br />Look carefully at fittings, finish, material qualities and overall appearance. Also investigate hull designs. They're bound to perform and handle differently which may help you deciding.
 
Top