Thanks to all for your help on this. I currently am running a 1962 Johnson 75 hp v-4 on a 16 ft '63 Aristocraft . It will go through 6 gal per hr at 30 mph or 6 gal in 45 min at 35 mph(WOT). I can back it down to say 20 and get approx 1hr 40 min out of the same 6 gal . I was hoping the 4 cycle I/O would cut fuel use close to 1/2. I guess the old v-4s aren't as thirsty as I thought.
I may try to find a 165 in the same boat. I'm just wanting a little bigger easier riding boat. Just have to figure paying a little more gas money for the luxury lol.If it was the same boat you may gain a little with the 140 but a 16' is a lot bigger than a 19' as far as motors are concerned. The 3.0l is small for a 19'. You are going to have to run it hard to get the boat going which hurts your GPH. Some would say you may get better GPH with a bigger motor since you will have to push it hard.