Ok, I finally did it...My 77' Johnson w/ 15 hp carb, no exhaust baffle, and open air silencer on a 1436 Duracraft "fisherman". I had my 5 gal gas tank 3/4 full, and a plastic box up front w/ some tools and such (maybe 20 lbs)...I stated w/ what I think is the original prop, 9.5x10, with the trim pin set second from the bottom, and on smooth water, it ran 23 mph fluxuating up to 23.5. The other prop was 9.25x8. It had noticably skinnier blades (possibly worn) and ran at higher rpms. Speed dropped to 21 mph. I honestly didn't expect there to be much of a difference since I lost rpms, but was pleasently supprised! The 10" pitch was smoother, and ran lower rpms which should be better on my motor. Just FYI.