Re: just put a different engine on my boat...which prop
Welcome,
We need more information.If you answer the information requested in the stickys at the top of the prop forum as best as you can we can help.
Prop selection especially on a pontoon can be difficult.
Depending on the information you get us both props are wrong. It might be possible to do a test run with the 17
and a very light load to get us some base numbers.You will probably end up with a 13" pitch as a starting point.
If you read the helps on the prop store page and the stickys mentioned it may give you a basic understanding of props.
We'll be glad to help with prop selection and any confusion.