My 1986 Sea Ray Seville II almost caught fire today...

floppybear

Cadet
Joined
Oct 30, 2019
Messages
12
It's my first post here...seems like a great community with lots of helpful info! I have been working on a 1986 19' Sea Ray Seville II Cuddy Cabin I recently picked up with a Mercruiser 170 and Alpha One Gen 1 outdrive, and closed cooling. I have done lots of work and all the routine maintenance, changed ignition to electronic, swapped starter, impeller, fluids, filters, plenty of 2-4-C involved, drained raw water out before winter, etc. The boat has been garage kept and seldom used its entire life, very well taken care of with the original manuals and lots of service receipts included. I had it running very well and was actually about to do my first water test (I know, I know, never buy a boat without a water test but it's in great condition and I saw it running well and for the price, if it floats it was a great deal).

Anyway, I decided to start the boat up on muffs at home to test my lower shift cable alignment before heading to the lake today. That's the first issue I have, the brass barrel on the lower shift cable will not budge and I don't want to force it and break something. Does anyone have a suggestion for that? It's a little bit rough going into reverse and shudders just a bit going into forward currently after putting the outdrive back on the boat.

On to the main story: I didn't realize at first what occurred today, but first I'll tell you what I witnessed. I attached the hose to the muffs and got in the boat to trim the motor up slightly so as not to have the prop hitting the gravel once the motor was started. I then hopped out of the boat and went over to the hose connection to turn the water on. I thought it was curious I heard what sounded like a pump in the bilge/transom area running when I walked towards the house to turn water on. No switches were on and no water was in the bilge (float switch works fine and manual switch for pump was off so I thought it was odd/interesting to hear a pump running as I walked away from the boat).

I then got back on the boat, put the key in the ignition, and attempted to start it up. All I got was a click from the solenoid (starter was working perfectly yesterday and nothing had changed) and then, the magic smoke. Emanating heavily from under the dashboard, seemingly centralized to the tachometer area, was wiring starting to become hot enough to melt, and white smoke pouring out. Of course, I immediately turned the key off and removed it from the ignition, but the smoke seemed to continue to intensify. I made a beeline for the battery and immediately disconnected the negative terminal. The smoke lessened, then stopped, and I began to try to diagnose what the heck happened to cause this almost catastrophic electrical fault.

After a bit of investigation, it appeared as though the black ground wire connected to the tachometer as well as the other instruments in the dash panel then going through the main wiring harness to the stern had decided to shed/melt its cable jacket in a dramatic fashion. I ended up pulling the whole wire harness out from its zip tie supports to check what damage was done. It seems as though I caught it in time to A. prevent a large fire and B. seemingly prevent damage to most or all other wires in the harness. Pretty much all that got hot enough to melt was the black ground wire and the melting only barely made its way into the harness where all the wires join together to run aft.

I followed the wires aft and also consulted the diagrams in the boat manual (which I have included here). I found that nothing really melted except that one black ground wire across the instruments and just barely into the harness. Damage to other cables seems very limited and the worst I found is part of the black ground cable's jacket melted onto the jacket of one or two other wires in a couple of places, but no significant damage to those other wires themselves. I plan to continuity test as much as I can with a meter from one end of the harness to the other.

After I took a better look in the transom area, I figured out what caused this whole thing. Going back to when I slightly trimmed the motor up before attempting to start it up, I found that a black cable with 2 conductors had come loose and was pinched inside when I trimmed the outdrive up. One end of this cable goes to the 50 amp breaker on the motor, with both conductors connected to the breaker. I noticed that the screw on one of the breaker terminals was a bit, uhhh "browned". The other end of this cable I believe goes to the power trim pump area, where it splits off to a blue white and a purple white wire, and those are also hooked into to the main wire harness.

So, what I think happened to cause the fault is when I trimmed the drive up, this wire got pinched and caused an electrical short causing a pump to run continuously (I may have burned out the pump as I don't think it was still running when I got back to the boat but I may be remembering this incorrectly because the smoke was a more immediate concern and more memorable at the time until I disconnected the battery). I then tried to start the motor, and voltage went where it shouldn't have, because somehow the tachometer became the most efficient path for this short to try to ground out. This thin wire clearly couldn't handle the excessive current and began to melt. When I removed the key, the smoke continued, so the fault theoretically had to involve something that gets power with no ignition or switches turned on, just 12v direct from the battery. This includes the radio, the bilge pump, and the outdrive trim.

So anyway, I know what happened at least, and I still have a boat that I can probably repair. I'm somewhat skilled with wiring and comfortable with most aspects of especially DC low voltage wiring (and I know that current in DC circuits can easily be enough to cause a fire, especially after today). I'm wondering if any of you fine folks would be willing to take a look at the wiring diagrams and try to help me determine what needs to be replaced to make my boat electrically safe again.

Of course, at a minimum anything that is melted needs to be completely replaced. It wouldn't be too big of an issue to run a new ground wire from the battery up to the dashboard area. However, I'm concerned about potential damage I can't see in the other wires in the harness (they appear totally fine with one or two spots where the black wire was touching but didn't damage the jacket of other wires). If I test impedance and continuity of the other wires in the harness, would that be a sufficient method to ensure that those other wires are still functional and safe?

The other thing I'm concerned about is the 50 amp breaker. It obviously didn't function as intended, but that's almost definitely because I crushed/shorted two of the wires connected to it. That screw got hot enough to turn brown, but nothing is melted and that appears to be the only visible damage. Would it be wise to replace the whole breaker? I can easily replace the wires that were crushed and the replace the melted black ground wire in the harness with a new one, but I want to make sure I'm not missing anything that could be important before hooking this all back up and having something go wrong.

In the meantime, I've ordered a 50 amp breaker to wire directly to the battery terminal to act as a main breaker to prevent a catastrophic fault like this from happening again. However, that would prevent the bilge pump float switch from operating if the breaker is tripped. Shouldn't be an issue as I trailer my boat and I would know the breaker isn't tripped if I'm on the boat using it, but maybe I should just wire just the bilge pump direct to the battery and everything else through the breaker?

Anyways, please help me determine what needs to be checked out and done here! Sorry for the long post. And thanks in advance for any advice.
 

floppybear

Cadet
Joined
Oct 30, 2019
Messages
12
[No message]
 

Attachments

  • photo330878.jpg
    photo330878.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 8
  • photo330880.jpg
    photo330880.jpg
    1.2 MB · Views: 8
  • photo330883.jpg
    photo330883.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 7

achris

More fish than mountain goat
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
27,468
Sounds like you have everything wired up off the engine harness. This is the first thing you need to rectify. Keep engine electrics and 'boat' electrics separate and on different busses.

The only thing that should be added to the engine instrument harness are a fuel gauge and an hourmeter. For everything else (GPS, sounder, nav and interior lights, blowers, pump, noise boxes, radios) run a independent red/black pair (about 6mm square), from the battery switch, through a 60A breaker and up to a red and a black terminal box either behind or under the dash. Everything 'non-engine' comes from there. That way, when things go badly, you aren't left completely 'dead in the water'.. If you have an engine electrical problem, you still have radios and pumps, etc to call for help and stop you sinking, and a failure of an ancillary system won't stop you getting home. Also, being set up like that will lead to it being less likely you'll have a fault anyway.

Chris........

These are what I use.
Click image for larger version  Name:	Terminal blocks.JPG Views:	1 Size:	46.0 KB ID:	10870661
 

floppybear

Cadet
Joined
Oct 30, 2019
Messages
12
Sounds like you have everything wired up off the engine harness.

The boat should be wired exactly as it was from the factory. Nothing has changed besides me wiring in an electronic ignition, a new starter, and a new ignition cylinder in the dashboard.

Are you saying that I need to change the way the boat was originally wired to isolate the other electronics from the motor? I'm guessing it would need 10 or 12 gauge wire at best to handle the potential current load. Why a 60A breaker and not a 50 like on the motor?

Do you have any ideas on what I might have fried and why, seeing as I severed or pinched the wires going to the power trim pump and then into the wiring harness? The tachometer appeared to take the brunt of the damage but hopefully the instruments are OK, and just the severed wire to the trim pump as well as the melted instrument common ground wire need to be replaced, best case scenario.

Unfortunately, none of the local shops will even touch this boat due to its age. I have a local certified Merc mechanic who can help me out if I'm in a pinch, but taking it to the shop is not an option. I have tried at least 5 local repair shops and they all say the boat is too old for them to work on.
 

achris

More fish than mountain goat
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
27,468
The boat should be wired exactly as it was from the factory.

That doesn't mean it's right. Most (all) installers are just after the quickest, cheapest job, and so will 'shortcut' anything they can. And not running a separate accessory electrical system is one way to save time and money.

Nothing has changed besides me wiring in an electronic ignition, a new starter, and a new ignition cylinder in the dashboard.

Are you saying that I need to change the way the boat was originally wired to isolate the other electronics from the motor?

Yes, that's EXACTLY what I'm saying. I have not seen a single boat from new that was wired correctly. Those that are right, have been changed by owners after the purchase.

I'm guessing it would need 10 or 12 gauge wire at best to handle the potential current load. Why a 60A breaker and not a 50 like on the motor?

60A, 50A, matters little. If you want to use the same as the one on the engine, fine. Just as long as you have a breaker in the circuit, of sufficient capacity for your anticipated load. As for wire size, use 6mm square (no idea what that is in imperial), and as USA is a metric country (see Metric Act 1866 and Metric Conversion Act 1975) I only use metric measurements :D...

Do you have any ideas on what I might have fried and why, seeing as I severed or pinched the wires going to the power trim pump and then into the wiring harness? The tachometer appeared to take the brunt of the damage but hopefully the instruments are OK, and just the severed wire to the trim pump as well as the melted instrument common ground wire need to be replaced, best case scenario.

Without physically looking, I can't tell. I would be in there with meters and such, but that's me.

Unfortunately, none of the local shops will even touch this boat due to its age. I have a local certified Merc mechanic who can help me out if I'm in a pinch, but taking it to the shop is not an option. I have tried at least 5 local repair shops and they all say the boat is too old for them to work on.

Yeah, hear that crap a lot... 'Too old to work on..' Bollocks! My 1972 boat is probably cleaner and it's certainly easier to work on that anything produced in the last 15 years!

Chris......
 
Last edited:

searcyfarms

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Mar 6, 2013
Messages
31
been there heard that...........wont work on my old 84 crestline with a 488 in it, same motor as yours i presume but with a 4bbl carb. I had a similar smokig issue but mine turned out to be the trim wiring that goes out thru the hull - basically bypassed the trim portion and wired direct w/out the gauge in play and it works fine, the old wiring gets to cracking from age and tends to flake off the insulation and well there you have it.......shorts...........smoke..........

sounds like you have a good handle on it - good job
 

achris

More fish than mountain goat
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
27,468
I've just been through and added up my electrical loads on the boat... It adds up fast!

These are the maximum current requirements using either the manufacturer's specifications, or the wattage of the bulbs (for lights)...

Yes, before any of the smart-alexs out there in internet land say anything, it's unlikely I would ever have all of these on drawing maximum power at the same time. But when specifying wire and fuse sizes, that's exactly how you plan it...

Chris.....


Current draws.JPG
 

tank1949

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Apr 4, 2013
Messages
1,911
That doesn't mean it's right. Most (all) installers are just after the quickest, cheapest job, and so will 'shortcut' anything they can. And not running a separate accessory electrical system is one way to save time and money.



Yes, that's EXACTLY what I'm saying. I have not seen a single boat from new that was wired correctly. Those that are right, have been changed by owners after the purchase.



60A, 50A, matters little. If you want to use the same as the one on the engine, fine. Just as long as you have a breaker in the circuit, of sufficient capacity for your anticipated load. As for wire size, use 6mm square (no idea what that is in imperial), and as USA is a metric country (see Metric Act 1866 and Metric Conversion Act 1975) I only use metric measurements :D...



Without physically looking, I can't tell. I would be in there with meters and such, but that's me.



Yeah, hear that crap a lot... 'Too old to work on..' Bollocks! My 1972 boat is probably cleaner and it's certainly easier to work on that anything produced in the last 15 years!

Chris......

and by 1986, Mgs hadn't experienced 34+ years of law suits due to their "bone-headedness."
 

floppybear

Cadet
Joined
Oct 30, 2019
Messages
12
That doesn't mean it's right. Most (all) installers are just after the quickest, cheapest job, and so will 'shortcut' anything they can. And not running a separate accessory electrical system is one way to save time and money.



Yes, that's EXACTLY what I'm saying. I have not seen a single boat from new that was wired correctly. Those that are right, have been changed by owners after the purchase.



60A, 50A, matters little. If you want to use the same as the one on the engine, fine. Just as long as you have a breaker in the circuit, of sufficient capacity for your anticipated load. As for wire size, use 6mm square (no idea what that is in imperial), and as USA is a metric country (see Metric Act 1866 and Metric Conversion Act 1975) I only use metric measurements :D...



Without physically looking, I can't tell. I would be in there with meters and such, but that's me.



Yeah, hear that crap a lot... 'Too old to work on..' Bollocks! My 1972 boat is probably cleaner and it's certainly easier to work on that anything produced in the last 15 years!

Chris......

Thanks for the info...it appears as though electronics currently have their own separate ground and power wires to the battery (I have three red and three black cables attached to the battery). Still, I'm not sure if it's isolated as you describe, and there definitely isn't a dedicated red/black to a terminal block near the dash as you described. I ordered a 50A breaker that should arrive today in order to isolate electronics and give them their own breaker. I plan to wire everything BUT the large power wire to the motor to this breaker. Would this be achieving what you describe to ensure that they are protected from short? The screw on my existing breaker got very hot and browned but for some reason it didn't open to stop the short circuit, and therefore I very nearly had a fire. Could be because I had two of the wires coming off of that breaker pinched in my outdrive. :facepalm::facepalm::facepalm:

Since I am needing to do a bit of rewiring anyway, I will see about ensuring that electronics are isolated. My boat has a fuel gauge but no hour meter. I certainly could wire the terminal block up near the dash like you specified, but it would require a bit of rethinking of my overall wiring/grounding scheme. Yes, I know metric is the bees knees, but the wire I can buy here in the US is sold by AWG. I'll just do the calculation to ensure that I'm not pulling more current than the new wire gauge can handle without heating up.

I have been doing a bit more investigation and I believe what happened is that somehow my ignition coil grounded out to the tachometer. I recently installed a Pertronix electronic ignition to replace my points. It was working great, until this happened. I'm not sure where or how the short occurred, but somehow my tachometer became the recipient of significantly more current than its small gauge ground wire could handle.

The boat didn't start smoking until I cranked the starter, and at that point I heard a click from the solenoid, but instead of reaching the starter, that current fried my tach wiring. The only melted wire was the instrument panel ground for the tach and other instruments, besides ancillary wires that were only slightly affected (I will pull out a meter and continuity/impedance test these wires as well as testing for shorts to adjacent wires).

Edit: I should also mention that the small instrument ground wire melted from the dashboard all the way back to the stern, just before the harness goes into the transom (where the small ground wire and two others join up with a larger gauge ground wire that goes directly to the battery. The larger cable was able to handle the current without melting, but the smaller wire is toast. Luckily this limited the damage to forward of the transom, and only one harness is affected (maximum of 8 wires in the harness that would possibly need to be replaced if they don't pass meter test).

Again, thanks for your assistance and insights! I am learning more every day about both electricity and boats. My usual career involves temporary wiring and safely handling dangerous levels of current, but I'm definitely not an expert quite yet by any means (I know enough to do basic wiring safely and prevent injury/death), and marine DC wiring is a slightly different beast.

Edit 2: Looks like according to this handy table, 6mm square wiring is approximately somewhere between a 9 and a 10 gauage AWG, which is not too far off from what I was thinking. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/a...uge-d_731.html
 
Last edited:

floppybear

Cadet
Joined
Oct 30, 2019
Messages
12
So today, I started by testing the ignition at the dashboard. Turns out, purple and yellow-red wires were totally shorted, but they were still shorted even when disconnected from the new ignition cylinder at the dashboard. I first surmised that maybe the melting black ground wire melted those two wires together somewhere along the harness, causing a short. However, this is an egg-before-chicken situation and obviously the short must have happened first to cause the melting tach ground wire. The pinched wires also don't seem to be at all related since the short still exists after severing the pinched part.

I traced continuity and impedance as well as testing for shorts along the whole wire harness. A smaller dashboard harness will need to be partially or totally replaced, but luckily the entire main engine harness is fine along its length. I then removed the harness connector at the motor side, and the short between purple and yellow-red was gone, meaning that something on the motor side was causing the short, and amazingly the whole engine harness tested out fine, at least from multipin to multipin.

In the wiring diagram I posted, purple goes from the ignition at the dash to the choke, and then has a purple resistance wire to the starter slave solenoid, which joins up with a purple-yellow wire at the positive side of the ignition coil.

Firstly, I determined that my new electronic ignition needs a 3 ohm coil while my factory coil was only 1.5 ohms and had no ballast resistor (oops, my Merc mechanic friend told me it was just plug and play). Not sure if that caused any problems but I've ordered the proper coil. Secondly, the only place where I see both purple-yellow and yellow-red meeting together is at the starter slave solenoid. I tested for continuity from the yellow-red wire on the front side of the solenoid (with the wire disconnected) to the purple-yellow terminal on the front of the solenoid, and read about 8 ohms. Is there supposed to be any current passing between these terminals on the front of the slave solenoid? Could it be a bad solenoid maybe?

Somehow, when I attempted to start the boat, the voltage must have reached the purple resistance wire to the choke, and passed from there onto the purple wire in the harness and from there to the dash instrument ground wire. The screw at the choke ground is also a bit browned but clearly the path of least resistance seemed to be, ironically enough, the purple resistance wire.

So, I've narrowed this down to either an issue with the choke, or the starter slave solenoid, I believe. I'm guessing that current shouldn't freely pass from the purple-yellow to yellow-red on the front of the starter slave solenoid. Luckily after deeper examination, the damage seems to be really limited in terms of what I'll need to rewire.
 

achris

More fish than mountain goat
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
27,468
Sounds like you're making progress. Well done.
 
Top