It's not a flat tappet luckily, so I don't have to break in the cam or anything. The coupler is fine, I had it off when I swapped motors and it looked good. If I put it in gear while running, the prop spins as it should. I'm wondering if I just need to run it a little longer and rev it up a little more to get the pump to start sucking. Maybe I'll put the known working old impeller back in just to see what happens.