First thing I would do is verify that your tach is correct. With these numbers assuming you have the 2:1 gear, your slip is 13.5 which is good. a drop to 15p should land you around 5100 rpm and accounting for you slip 31.22mph. The drop to a 13P should put you around 5500 and accounting for slip 29.35mph. If your happy with your boats performance I would go with the 15 but if you want to improve your acceleration and hole shot the 13 may be in order.