Re: prop size
Sounds like your prop is probably pretty close and your tach is off. I might try checking the little switch on the back of the tach, move it back and forth a few times and then make sure it is set on 8 cylinder...
or borrow a shop tack, or even a digital timing light with a tach function built in and run it to see how it reads.
(note to second poster. assuming you have standard 1,81 gear for a 4.3, there's on the order of 4-5" pitch equivelent difference in gear ratios for your boats. his 19 is more like a 23+ on your boat...)