since plugs 3&4 have been steam cleaned, we can assume that either the head gasket is gone or the exhaust manifold/riser is leaking or the head is cracked
Rinker85 , fresh water or salt water?
any rust trails from the manifold to elbow gasket joint?
when was the last time you had the manifold off and pressure tested?
did you do a compression test?
I do believe there are rust trails