To seal, consider WOG's sealant of 1 qt linseed oil, 2 qts. mineral spirits, and 1 qt. spar varnish.
I have some extra pieces of laminated joists that I've been using for motor mounts. Stuff is really heavy duty, as one would expect -- to my eye, similar to marine plywood, but thick. Very dense, no voids -- stuff I have is approx. 2 inches thick. If you can locate a piece of that at your lumber yard, might be worth a look. Mine was left over from construction of my garage -- not sure what you would run into if trying to buy a section of the stuff.
But I've used the usual double layer 3/4 ply many times, and never a problem -- construction grade for this is fine. Do not use treated ply. I recommend epoxy or 5200 to bond, along with drywall screws. Seal the whole piece with epoxy or WOG's brew, with special attention to the edges. For a two inch thickness, sandwich in a piece of half inch ply.