My suggestion would be to identify if you have a "Keelshield" or a "Keel Guard". If you go to each of their websites, you will find an identifying picture of their product. Keelguard.com shows their product with longitudinal lines more concentrated toward the center of the guard(3 lines) with no lines toward the outer edges (about an inch or so). Conversely, at gator-guards.com for the Keel guard, you will notice their product has numerous and continuous longitudinal lines (about 6 on each side of center) the entire width of the guard. These 2 choices are very different in appearance and should be easy to identify if indeed yours is one of them. If you are lucky enough to identify, then I would go to my first suggestion and contact them about the adhesive failure and request a replacement as each of their websites say lifetime warranty. If you cannot positively id your particular keel protector as one of these, then I would pull it off, prep the keel, removing any lingering adhesive, and replace with one of the above mentioned products. I think trying to work against gravity and somehow support the existing guard to wait for cure time on any adhesive will be futile and messy. Just my nickel's worth(2 cents are for boys-girls are way more expensive...but not always worth it!) Good luck.