The post WW2 flywheels are much improved, and have never had a 50s OMC with bad flywheel magnets. Maybe if you left the flywheel off the motor for a hundred years or so it may weaken, but nothing you will have to worry about. I doubt that is the issue. I find your symptoms are almost ALWAYS dirty points. Even when new, they often need cleaning and dressing. Wrap wet/dry around a hacksaw blade, and polish those buggers to a shine. Blow off with compressed air. Dip business card or paper stock in acetone and run that through. This is after verifying they are set correctly at 020. How is the coils air gap? Maybe too big?
I pulled flywheel and dressed (again) points with 320 grit. Sprayed clean with electronic contact cleaner and wiped with paper stock. Reset at 0.020. Coil air gap set with Franks ring from this site. Absolutely ZERO spark on spark tester, which is good and my 1957 Fastwin makes it pop. If I ground the spark plug to the block it sparks the plug gap 0.030...so spark is weak. Everything is new on the ignition and redone several times. I can see having one cylinder that wasn't sparking if I happened to have got a faulty coil or condenser...but I highly doubt that all the brand new coils, condensers and points are faulty. What else could it be other than the flywheel? The magnet looks fine. I do see where at some point there was rubbing on the coils and it left some marks...but not damaged or any chunks missing.
Man...I don't know what else to do to get some sparkage??