Re: 1972 Starcraft SS 18' 140 Mercruiser
Even though it's all Rusto, I probably wouldn't mix their products unless they were from the SAME product line. But that's because I don't know that much about paint chemistry or Rusto's different product mixes.
Did you just buy the 2qts of Navy? If so, I'd take 1 back & swap it for a qt of white, and probably buy another qt of white, or just a gallon of white for the difference in price between qts & gallons. All Rustoleum Pro:
I don't think it takes much BLUE to tint white to baby blue. I think it'll take ALOT of white to tint navy blue to baby blue......
If you've had the navy for a while, it'd be worth the $30+/- to me to buy a gallon of white Rusto Pro.
It's not a small thing to paint an entire boat, so I'd only want to do it once if I can help it.
To that end, here's 3 more suggestions:
1) Use a good respirator system & add enamel hardener to the paint. It'll increase the scratch resistance & increase the gloss of the paint.
2) You can NOT do to much paint prep, and using all the same product line from Rusto falls into this category. Like I said, I rather only do it once, and spending extra time to prep & an extra $20-30 to buy more paint would be well worth it, IMHO.
3) Follow WOG's paint tips here (Rusto is an enamel similar to the Majic & Tractor Supply paint he discusses):
"Paint Your Boat for Under $100 Bucks...Well Almost"
On the cowl vents, if you're buying white (or for just these use the topside paint you already have) sand them as smooth as you can, fill the pits w/ JB Weld, sand & paint prep them (for bare aluminum don't forget a light coat of ZC or SE, same for the boat) and shoot them white. They'll look pretty good white against a light blue hull, sort of like SP's MFG:
Before:
After: