Most every dealer, BassPro, Cabela's etc stocks those factory fiber washers, I buy them by the dozen so I have them on hand. As far as the screws go, I use what is called a " low head" hex head cap screw to replace drain screws if the dealer doesn't have replacements. They have a large head with a flat underside for a washer. In some cases the head dia was a little large so I chucked it up in a drill and spun it on a belt sander to the correct size. Quick, simple, easy and cheap and it works perfectly. Have used the nylon/ fiber washers in a pinch with no issues. If they were to absorb any water it would be so minut it would not matter. Little things like these , I try to keep a couple spares on hand, well worth the few bucks they cost..and saves chasing them down when you really need them !!