Gun control in Australia c&p

QC

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
22,783
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

What the US thing, the Canada thing, the Aussie thing, the Cutlery thing and the Switzerland thing prove is that it is Values that determine if people kill each other. Doesn't matter if it is a Suicide bomber, a knife, a fist, Concentration camps, machetes or a Thermonuclear device . . . (yes, I know we are the only ones to use one, it was agonised over, and it was determined as a way ultimately of saving lives, if you don't believe that, look it up.)

BTW, I do not believe that the cutlery thing is ridiculous good friend Aldo. Yes, guns make some of these evil acts easier and that is problematic, but it does not change the fact that evil people kill innocents in any way they can figure out . . .
 

OldMercsRule

Captain
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
3,340
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

As we have discussed before: THE USA is a very different Country then our English speaking cousins or parent. Our rights come from a place well beyond the elite Emperor, Dictator or even a mere Monarch, Congress or Parlament. Our rights come from the big fella: OUR CREATOR. That is a profoundly different situation then our English speaking relatives that we share so much in common.

Our Country is the most sucessfull Country that has ever existed at this brief moment in time, our parent and cousins are also quite successful Countries as well, but we, (the USA) are the magnet for the world at large today, (our mother Country once was the magnet of the world and still is a very sucessfull Country over the wonderfull history of the English system). The most agressive and ambitious people from all over the world come here to work hard and prosper. I and many Cornservatives choose to maintain our God given rights to bear arms, the Liberals amoung us who seem to revel in creating disasters for our Country want to redifine our rights with simantics and Tyrants in black robes, but we hopefully will not let them corntrol that aspect of our lives.


The favorite way for the domestic Libs n' Democrats to change our system, (and corntrol us and hopefully put us to sleep so we cede our rights to them), is to dream up some sort of sympathy for someone who has suffered a relatively rare misfortune, and dumb down the whole sytem of Laws to deal with the rare problem or some idiot victim's problems. I would rather a few extra guns out in the system, (and the potential cornsequences that the MSM will always try to used to dumb down the system), as long as I can own guns and protect my own family without the approval of a bureacrat, Monarch or Dictator THANK YOU VERY MUCH: MRS JONES!!! Leave the 911 calls to the big city Liberals, (that seem to luv to put themselves at the mercy of the system) by the time they get to my place: the emergancy will be dealt with. Respectfully JR
 

Dunaruna

Admiral
Joined
May 2, 2003
Messages
6,027
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

Yes, guns make some of these evil acts easier and that is problematic, but it does not change the fact that evil people kill innocents in any way they can figure out . . .

I totally agree (notice that I didn't include the cutlery quote :p).

From where I sit, apart from hunting/sporting uses and law enforcement, firearms have no place in society. Maybe it's a cultural thing - dunno.
I vote for the political party that I think will best service my needs - education, health, public services, local and broader security. If they get it wrong they get voted out next time. I don't love my politicians, they are not heros or celebrities, they are paid to do a job and can (and often do) get fired when they get it wrong.

A nutcase went postal and killed 35 people with an automatic assault rifle, people (voters) started asking questions like 'what the hell is a mentally unstable person doing with an assault rifle?' The elected officials responded. This isn't rocket science, it's a fair response to a fair question.

As I have already said, anybody in this country can apply for a permit and buy a firearm.

To suggest that they will now target cutlery IS rediculous.
To suggest that I do not have free will or freedom of speech is even more rediculous, almost insulting. I love my country the very same way you love your's.
 

OldMercsRule

Captain
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
3,340
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

I totally agree (notice that I didn't include the cutlery quote :p).

From where I sit, apart from hunting/sporting uses and law enforcement, firearms have no place in society. Maybe it's a cultural thing - dunno.

Yes Dunaruna, it is a cultural thing. Unlike our Auzzie n Canadian cousins or our English Parents we, (some of us: generally Cornservatives), Americans have a built in distrust of any and all governments, (except Liberals who seem to want to transfer as much of their fellow citizens income and power to the government as they can regardless of how foundational the citizen's rights maybe) . I totally respect your opinion and in your system you and your fellow subjects or the Queen can effect your fellow subjects abilities to possess firearms, because you have no fundamental right to have the guns. Here the deal is VERY different and they will need to pry my cold dead fingers from my gun after kickin' down my door. So bottom line: people or fellow citizens can have any opinion they want about a gus "place in society"; they just can't impose their opinion on me over the matter of gun possession: PERIOD.

I vote for the political party that I think will best service my needs - education, health, public services, local and broader security. If they get it wrong they get voted out next time. I don't love my politicians, they are not heros or celebrities, they are paid to do a job and can (and often do) get fired when they get it wrong.

Not much different here.

A nutcase went postal and killed 35 people with an automatic assault rifle, people (voters) started asking questions like 'what the hell is a mentally unstable person doing with an assault rifle?' The elected officials responded. This isn't rocket science, it's a fair response to a fair question.

I know how the argument is to dumb the system down to the lowest denominator ya can find. We get the same arguments here. If I'm out on me boat with me family, n' some nasties come lookin' to have their way with me and mine, they will have to eat a lead sandwitch well before the police could possibly show up to put me and my family in the body bags they bring to carry away the bad guys I would have planted as soon as the risk is known. Some big city Libs like to depend on dialing 911 for all their needs, not ol' Murky!

As I have already said, anybody in this country can apply for a permit and buy a firearm.

Yah, those who luv to have their rights, (actualy there is no right it is a privledge that can be granted or denied), doled out or denied by government workers who give the best customer service, (just think about the last time ya got a drivers license), can have that system and I wish them well. Just don't impose what you want on me. Real simple.

To suggest that they will now target cutlery IS rediculous.
To suggest that I do not have free will or freedom of speech is even more rediculous, almost insulting. I love my country the very same way you love your's.

Don't know about cutlery, but the freedom of yer speech and will may actually come from a grant of the Queen, (not sure how the Auzzie rights are legally granted), and what can be givin' by a mere mortal can be taken away when the reason to take it away vests with the party who holds that power over you in the first place. I guess that is why I'm a proud American. I mean no disrespect or insult. It is what it is. Respectfully JR
 

Vlad D Impeller

Commander
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
2,644
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

The Aussies get to decide whats good or bad for their country, as does Americans decide what is good for theirs.
 

OldMercsRule

Captain
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
3,340
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

The Aussies get to decide whats good or bad for their country, as does Americans decide what is good for theirs.

No Vlad there really is a profound difference that I sure hope you can see. I do not live here in America under the perview of anyone about my fundamental rights as derived from my creator and codified in a document at the very foundation of the republic under which I live, (the Cornstatution). This is not fuzzy wuzzy stuff. The other English speaking Countries can follow the feelings of their fellow subjects/pols/leaders about their temporary or transitory rights as granted by the Queen or their leaders/fellow subjects all they want and they are fine with that system and I accept that. The Liberals here want the same ability to take away my rights, (because of their 'feelings' or desire to corntrol me and others), that the other Countries have and that is worth fighting for IM not so HO. THAT IS WHAT MAKES THIS AMERICA: MY FRIEND!!!!!! Respectfully, JR
 

QC

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
22,783
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

A nutcase went postal and killed 35 people with an automatic assault rifle, people (voters) started asking questions like 'what the hell is a mentally unstable person doing with an assault rifle?' The elected officials responded. This isn't rocket science, it's a fair response to a fair question.
It is a fair question, but the unfair answer is we can't uninvent them . . . Anyone that wants one bad enough will get one no matter what the legislation. It's a big issue, but for me the only answer is that I wish just one of those 35 innocent people had a gun and was a good shot . . . ;)

Our issue here is that we see permiting as the first step towards confiscation. We do reguire permits for handguns, but not rifles or shotguns. We also hold the people's right to bear arm as the greatest symbol of our freedom from a potentially opressive Government. Yes, when things are good that sounds silly, but things are known not to be so good forever . . .
 

ZmOz

Captain
Joined
Aug 13, 2003
Messages
3,949
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

We do reguire permits for handguns, but not rifles or shotguns.

Not here they don't. (OR) You can buy as many of whatever kind of gun you want with no permits so long as you don't try to conceal it. You can also buy a muzzleloading gun via mail in most states (I believe excluding CA) with nothing more than a credit card. That's the way I think it should be with all guns...muzzleloaders kill the same as anything else yet there hasn't been any problem allowing them to be sold this way. As you say, we can't uninvent them....pot is illegal for most people, does that mean nobody smokes it? Gun legislation is as pointless as that "WARNING: HOT" label on coffee cups. Criminals don't buy their guns at Walmart.
 

Dunaruna

Admiral
Joined
May 2, 2003
Messages
6,027
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

OMR, you make a compelling argument as to why it is important to maintain YOUR right to bear arms but I am yet to see a compelling argument as to how that relates/compares to us. After all, a comparison is the theme of the thread.

I get a little hot under the collar when our cultural differences become a slinging match. I (and most aussies) don't give gun control in this country or the opposing view in your country a second thought, it's just not on the radar. The only reason it get's media is when it becomes a political football for your pro gun.

It goes without saying that I (like most fathers) would do anything to protect my family but carrying a handgun on a family boating trip is such an alien concept to me because there is no threat (I must confess, I take a shotgun when we go fishing for sharks), there is nothing to protect against. Same goes for our home. BUT, I understand and respect your right to protect your family as you see fit.

We have cultural and political differences. You like it your way, we like our way. If we ever get the chance to meet, let's discuss it over a beer or two.
 

ZmOz

Captain
Joined
Aug 13, 2003
Messages
3,949
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

It goes without saying that I (like most fathers) would do anything to protect my family but carrying a handgun on a family boating trip is such an alien concept to me because there is no threat

So there's no crime in Australia? Wow, must be nice...
 

Vlad D Impeller

Commander
Joined
Mar 30, 2005
Messages
2,644
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

So there's no crime in Australia? Wow, must be nice...

How does one not feeling threatened equates to no crime in Australia.
Crimes are commited in every country on planet earth. :rolleyes:
 

OldMercsRule

Captain
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
3,340
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

OMR, you make a compelling argument as to why it is important to maintain YOUR right to bear arms but I am yet to see a compelling argument as to how that relates/compares to us.

Thanks Dunaruna, It is a very American, (USA), corncept based upon our unique history and heritage, and the manner we broke away from our Mother Country which is very different from the way you folks and our other siblings did it. There are many Liberals here in Seattle and in this Great Country that share your, (and apparently Vlad's point of view about how society should not have guns). That is an 'option' in the political systems in England, Auzzieland, NZ, Canada, and many other Countries in the world, and I sense the majority of the world and many here lean the direction you do.

Does not matter: I will not voluntarily surrender any right the Cornstatution grants me, and a lot of Americans feel that same way I do. I never said nor ment to imply that your Country, (which I admire a great deal), should adopt the American, (USA) approach. I think our English parents and our siblings in Auzie, NZ, Canada share the basic confidence we all have in our respective systems, this is just a difference, (minor but IMHO very significant). We still share much in common, and our peoples' values are clearly the reason freedom exists in the ENTIRE world today. NO doubt in my mind about that. Had the Spanish, French, Germans or others ever beaten the English we would not have the world we now have, and freedom would not flourish as it does in our Countries and much of the world. That is no accident: my friend.


After all, a comparison is the theme of the thread.

I get a little hot under the collar when our cultural differences become a slinging match.

That: I appoligize for. It was not and is not my intention to make you, Vlad or any of my iboats friends "hot under the collar", I made this point for my Countrymen as much as anything, as our public schools teach a lot about homosexuality and victimhood, but very little about what makes us unique and very important amoung the worlds' powers.

I (and most aussies) don't give gun control in this country or the opposing view in your country a second thought, it's just not on the radar.

Understood.

The only reason it get's media is when it becomes a political football for your pro gun.

I would call it 'pro foundational rights', Dunarana, as guns, (second amendment) is not nearly as important as the corncept of foundational rights, (it is just a symptom of the basic problem we have here dealing with Liberals anxious to cede as much of our rights as they can to the government). Example of this problem: I'm not a Republican I'm an Independent, but I can't stand any current Democrat presidential candidate (if Bill Richardson had not welcomed surrender to Islam I could possibly deal with him). I deeply admire on a personal level: John McCain and to a lesser extent Fred Thompson, although I would not politically support Mr. McCain because he ceded our freedom of speech to incumbent Pols in McCain Fiengold, and I have big reservations about Mr. Thompson for the same exact reason. I would still favor either over any current Democrat as every single current Democrat wants to pack the Judicial system with black robed tyrants to rewrite or reinterpret away all of our, (American's foundational rights), because they view our precious Cornstatution as a "living breathing document" to be flushed down the terlet and replaced with the Liberal European rule by elites. Not gonna agree to that without a fight: my friend!!!

It goes without saying that I (like most fathers) would do anything to protect my family but carrying a handgun on a family boating trip is such an alien concept to me because there is no threat (I must confess, I take a shotgun when we go fishing for sharks), there is nothing to protect against. Same goes for our home.

I also rarely pack my gun(s) Dunarama, if I'm at a place that I have a great deal of confidence in, but generally: I have a safely stored unloaded weapon and ammunition available if need be. (Two times in my life it was necessary to bring one out, but nothing happened because I had a 12 ga shot gun, [my favorite gun to have to equalize things, if need be], the main reason I prefer a shot gun is the immeadiate deterant effect it has on any potential bad guy or guys lookin down the big hole in the end). This Country has a much greater population then yours does, their are a lot of illegal immigrants, and because of the attractiveness of our system: the most agressive people in the world today are here in this Country. I'm really not as paranoid as this may come across, and I am very carefull with my artilery.


BUT, I understand and respect your right to protect your family as you see fit.

Thank You.

We have cultural and political differences. You like it your way, we like our way.

Agreed.

If we ever get the chance to meet, let's discuss it over a beer or two.

Hope that happens someday!! Respectfully, JR
 

QC

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
22,783
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

Not here they don't. (OR) You can buy as many of whatever kind of gun you want with no permits so long as you don't try to conceal it.
Sorry, I meant for concealed . . .
 

Bigprairie1

Commander
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
2,568
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

This is undoubtedly a great discussion forum. I have been out of the loop for a couple of weeks on vacation but in coming back 'on-line' its good to see some lively stuff going on...particularly the international viewpoints.
As a Canadian....I can vouch for basically what the (near complete) absence of gun culture or pro/con gun debate produces...which is, next to no interest in guns.
Most people don't have em'...don't want em'. We are a very peaceful country...not too much violent crime (still decreasing)...rising crime on the little stuff (like everyone I suppose). Murders are generally pretty big news. Our city is about 300,000+ people. We probably have.....10-15 murders a year? (just guessing but that seems about right).
I don't buy into the 'get rid of all guns debate'....that makes no sense. Certain firearms tho', particularly handguns...is a trickier issue. Assault weapons...definitely.
I would have to describe the daily 'Invader Threat Level' around my house as....well next to zero.
Anywhoooo, great discussion so far.....keep it going.
 

OldMercsRule

Captain
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
3,340
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

This is undoubtedly a great discussion forum. I have been out of the loop for a couple of weeks on vacation but in coming back 'on-line' its good to see some lively stuff going on...particularly the international viewpoints.
As a Canadian....I can vouch for basically what the (near complete) absence of gun culture or pro/con gun debate produces...which is, next to no interest in guns.
Most people don't have em'...don't want em'. We are a very peaceful country...not too much violent crime (still decreasing)...rising crime on the little stuff (like everyone I suppose). Murders are generally pretty big news. Our city is about 300,000+ people. We probably have.....10-15 murders a year? (just guessing but that seems about right).
I don't buy into the 'get rid of all guns debate'....that makes no sense. Certain firearms tho', particularly handguns...is a trickier issue. Assault weapons...definitely.
I would have to describe the daily 'Invader Threat Level' around my house as....well next to zero.
Anywhoooo, great discussion so far.....keep it going.

I do not deny that the USA is an active movin' n' shakin' place to live and work, and I for one: want it to stay that way. Freedom is not free in any way shape or form.

Canada is a good example of a relatively passive quite Liberal n' relatively sucessfull Socialistic society that economically dirives a great deal of positive business activity from their Southern sibling. The real agressive (and potentially nasty) people of the world generaly come here due to the economic opportunities, (although they may enter from our Northern Neighbor).

If the USA did not exist I would want to live in one of the English speaking sibling or parent Countries that I share the most common values with. That said: individual crime, (retail crime that the MSM focuses on to cornvince dim wit victims to dumb down our laws to deal with), in Joseph Stalins' or Chairman Mao's or Hitlers' Germany or Sadum's Iraq was also very rare. That is one of the pro autocrat arguments the Communist Professors used when I attended the University of Washington many moons ago, (ol' Murky had a few more brain cells in those days n' didn't buy their garbage then or I could be a Liberal now).

Michael Moore n' Chris Dodd can't say enough good things about Castro. Ya don't think there is a lot of retail crime in North Korea or Cuba do you? Be carefull of what ya wish for, a few murders from the retail sector useing guns is not a valid reason to make law abiding Citizens criminals by denying their God given rights to bear arms, (God given in the USA). It is just a cost of our, (USA's) freedom: real simple if ya have a functional brain cell. Respectfully JR
 

Bigprairie1

Commander
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
2,568
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

Be carefull of what ya wish for, a few murders from the retail sector useing guns is not a valid reason to make law abiding Citizens criminals by denying their God given rights to bear arms, (God given in the USA). It is just a cost of our, (USA's) freedom[/COLOR]

Now this is an interesting statement.
Based on my somewhat limited knowledge of the U.S constitution I was sure that the constiution enshrined (and thus ensured) a separation of 'Church and State'. Note: this is what tangled Europe into knots for hundreds of years was ensuring religious zealots and their 'god' of the moment did not overlord everyone else. Good governance was the purpose.
Religion is a very subjectiive thing...and a lot of people view it differently.
Thus, the concept of God (not the government?) giving the rights of firearm ownership...well....thats a bit of stretch. I going to have to check my bible on that one.
That said, dividing Church and State is fundamental in creating a very good governing foundation for society. Having religion even influence the other...is a frikkin' disaster wating to happen. Look at the middle east. Look at 'old' europe......melt down city.
If someone tells me to kneel and pray to their religion....I say, no way...and I don't care if they are Jewish, Muslim, Baptist, Anglican, whatever.....no way, no day.
 

Bigprairie1

Commander
Joined
Jun 13, 2007
Messages
2,568
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

Note: this is what tangled Europe into knots for hundreds of years was ensuring religious zealots and their 'god' of the moment did not overlord everyone else. Good governance was the purpose.

....ooops, sorry folks, my own mistake on this phrasing and the resultant point (...I got a bit ahead of myself here).
Point: This combining of Church w/ State ....never worked, it sucked. It brought Europeans to their knees at their own system. The U.S forefathers, to my understanding, said they were not going to make that mistake twice and a result seperated the two. (correct me if I'm wrong on this constitution point........being a Canadian and all)
Thus...good governance absolutely requires the two (Church and state) be completely separate to succeed.
 

OldMercsRule

Captain
Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Messages
3,340
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

Now this is an interesting statement.
Based on my somewhat limited knowledge of the U.S constitution I was sure that the constiution enshrined (and thus ensured) a separation of 'Church and State'.

You know more then most of the experts on victimhood who live here!!! Read the actual document. It is only 20 pages + or - with amendments, should not take long. Thomas Jefferson mused about the separtation of Church n' State it is not written ANYWHERE in the actual document. The good ol' MSM n' the dim wit Democtats are real good at givin' relatively informed people such as yerself a real acurate picture of this Country don't they???? That's why we Cornservatives call it Kool aid, (try to refrain from another drink n' go to the Library, ya may learn an actual fact or two)!! Religion is not outlawed it is not permissable for BIG GOVERNMENT to pick a STATE religion, (real simple). Our, (US Citizens') rights are "self evident" and come from "our Creator"!!! BTW: the Queen is not our Creator!!! The "bill of rights" I allude to here are incorporated the doc too!! Is that hard to grasp??????? I hope not!!!!


Note: this is what tangled Europe into knots for hundreds of years was ensuring religious zealots and their 'god' of the moment did not overlord everyone else. Good governance was the purpose.
Religion is a very subjectiive thing...and a lot of people view it differently.
Thus, the concept of God (not the government?) giving the rights of firearm ownership...well....thats a bit of stretch. I going to have to check my bible on that one.

No I'm not "stretchin" at all IN ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM. Read the US CORNSATUTION, (not yer bible), I'm not makin' this up!!!

That said, dividing Church and State is fundamental in creating a very good governing foundation for society. Having religion even influence the other...is a frikkin' disaster wating to happen. Look at the middle east. Look at 'old' europe......melt down city.

Yer orbiting another planet. Please read the actual doc it will sink in: eventually. This is very fundamental to understanding yer Sourthern neighbor!!

If someone tells me to kneel and pray to their religion....I say, no way...and I don't care if they are Jewish, Muslim, Baptist, Anglican, whatever.....no way, no day.

I'm not sayin' that at all. Please read my exact words not my mind, or what you think I said. Respectfully, JR
 

ZmOz

Captain
Joined
Aug 13, 2003
Messages
3,949
Re: Gun control in Australia c&p

How does one not feeling threatened equates to no crime in Australia.
Crimes are commited in every country on planet earth. :rolleyes:

If there is still crime how is one not threatened? I don't live in a bad neighborhood, there's been one murder in my town in the last decade, but I've got a loaded .45 next to my bed just in case. There are nut jobs waiting to kill/rob/rape you EVERYWHERE, including australia.
 
Top