The amphenol connectors are pretty easy to work with (some WD-40 or electrical cleaner to lubricate). But when you say the coils are "within tolerances", I wonder if maybe they are both less than perfect (even if it turned out they are both working). My guess is that it's the power pack, but guessing with your money. If you go to the marina, though, they should be able to tell you with some confidence if it's a coil or power pack, maybe for a half hours work.