Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Targa17

Recruit
Joined
Jan 9, 2010
Messages
3
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I boat a Tracker Targa 17 new in 1999. Loved it! Just sold it last month and bought a 2009 Targa V17. No complaints at all. Targa's are great boats!
 

robert graham

Admiral
Joined
Apr 16, 2009
Messages
6,908
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I bought a new Express "package" boat/motor in 1999 with a Yamaha 90HP 2 stroke. It's all welded, very durable and really maintenance free. At the time of purchase I also researched the Sea Ark boats, which are similar and very rugged, with many different models and styles up to 24' long. My express has .100" thick aluminum throughout while the Sea Arks are a bit heavier with .125", but you couldn't go wrong with either. A "package" boat comes all pre-rigged with your choice of consoles, live-wells, trolling motors, etc., etc. and seem to be priced very competively. My boat is an 1872 model which means 18' longe with a beam of 72" and I added a Bimini top, depth finder, galvanized trailer, stainless prop and bilge pump for about $11,500, but that was in 1999, so I'm sure prices have gone up. Check 'em out and good luck!
 

tpcowfish

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Dec 31, 2009
Messages
99
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I had two Trackers, didn't like them, cheaply built,goes with price, bought a crestliner, much different, more stable, better ride,very much better quality, Last Tracker was a targa 18, first time out windsheild wing came off, every screw inside boat was loose every time i came in. I say Lund ,alum craft, crestliner ect, you'll be happier, if you can spend a little more, they'll last a long time
 

slasmith1

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Dec 2, 2008
Messages
1,028
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I had two Trackers, didn't like them, cheaply built,goes with price, bought a crestliner, much different, more stable, better ride,very much better quality, Last Tracker was a targa 18, first time out windsheild wing came off, every screw inside boat was loose every time i came in. I say Lund ,alum craft, crestliner ect, you'll be happier, if you can spend a little more, they'll last a long time

If you really didn't like them why did you buy a second one?
 

northernmerc

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
401
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

A friend bought a used Tracker last year. It looks great and has lots of amenities, but it leaks. So far we haven't been able to find the source of the leak(s) and would rather not have to strip out the boat interior to find it.

My older 16 foot riveted Lund - 31 years old this year - doesn't leak a drop and is still as good as new.
 

tpcowfish

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Dec 31, 2009
Messages
99
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

If you really didn't like them why did you buy a second one?

The first one was a small boat just for messing around , the second was for The lake (Erie) where there were waves to deal with, I guess i am a slow learner, thot with my wallet instead of brain
 

bitterboater

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
May 7, 2009
Messages
214
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I personally have experience with Alumacraft, Fisher, and Lowe boats. My family has owned versions of all three.

The Alumacraft's we have had are my '67 16ft (owned for 16yrs, very happy with it) and my fathers 1997 18ft also very happy with that one.

The Fisher we had was very shallow, and tippy (IMO) {was not a good summer for me as I had recently been in a boating accident} owned that one for 2 years and replaced it with the '97 Alumacraft that my father still has. I will say that the Yamaha 40 motor on the fisher ran very, very quietly and smoothly.

The Lowe we had was the very first boat I can remember my family having. It was a basic 16ft guide series with a matching 40 hoarse Johnson motor. We owned that boat for the best part of 15 years. Only reason we replaced it was because it was the boat my father, brother and I were in at the time of our accident.

I would certainly buy another Alumacraft or Lowe boat as I have been very pleased with the ones I have used.
 

leer94

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
39
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

IMO....( at it is only an opinion and not sure about the price range being suitable)
Three really good Alum boats I have been around...

LegendCraft.
http://www.legendcraft.com/boats.htm
Small mom and pop style builder, but they will completely customize the boat to your wants and are supposed to be one tough little boat.

WarEagle
http://www.wareagleboats.com/
I know a guide who has one of these and he says this is the toughest little boat he has ever owned.

Polar Kraft
http://www.polarkraftboats.com/
 

steelespike

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Apr 26, 2002
Messages
19,069
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

I would steer away from the Tracker.There have been plenty of posts here over the years about cracked welds,weak bottoms etc.
I think the specs are missleading. cap.4 persons,560lbs that's 140lbs per person
I don't know very many guys at that weight.Total cap. 1,050 lbs 4 persons,at 140,live well,20 gal gas motor = 1,048.Doesn't leave much for gear,beverages battery,anchors etc. is the 1,050 over and above the trolling motor and battery?
89" beam I'll bet thats at the transom 60 wide bottom probably also at the transom.
While its probably pretty stable may not be much actual room.
 

wa_ssv197

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
266
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

until I got my glastron I have only been around aluminum boats.

A 1987 17' BlueFin (bayliner)
A 1987 Lund 14'
and a 199~ 19' Lund Pro

The BlueFin would be fine if it didn't have the gutless Force 50 on it.
The 14' Lund Has a 25hp Johnson on it and is our fishing boat to this day, not a leak in the boat.
The 19' Lund is our neighbors and it has a 125hp on it and pulls wakboarders with ease. Its dual consoles and a front seat post mount make it a good all around fish/ski boat.
 

blu72nova

Recruit
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
5
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Thanks everyone! I have been going to a few boat shows to see what else is out there and pricing some boats. Does anyone have or have experience with G3 boats? I have a friend who has one and he really likes his. But other than that I haven't heard much about them. Any additional input is useful.
 

cwhite6

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
348
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

One of my friends has a 16' G3 bass boat. It is really nice and he loves it. Better made than a Tracker. I still like the Xpress boats better though.
 

lcdr frank

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
May 25, 2008
Messages
36
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Try looking at the Duroboat. No welds and no rivets. Unique construction, strong, light weight. The co is in the process of moving to Tenn as we speak. I have a 15 ft 30rude. It has excellent rough water handling, good freeboard. I am looking at a 16 ft/40hp. Lookup there web site.


Frank
 

Expidia

Commander
Joined
Aug 26, 2006
Messages
2,368
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

My take . . . 3 years ago I went through the same decision you have to make. Money was of course always an issue.

I had in my sights the Alumacraft 145 because for the money you can't beat the value and quality of an Alumacraft boat.

But when I went stopped by this dealer in Connecticut he had the Alumacraft and a similar Lund model side by side because he just brought the rigs back from a boat show.

I was able to get into the Alumacraft and check it out. The Lund was like $3500 more and I said to myself what could possibly be worth $3500 more for the exact same size boat???

Well once I plopped myself into the Lund . . . . That's all she wrote. I didn't buy from that dealer because he was asking list prices and wouldn't budge. So I haggled around with my local dealer and paid around 13-14k for a new 2007 15 footer with a 40hp 4 stroke Merc and the trailer.

You need to actually sit in a perspective rig. A test drive is even better. Go to a boat show. Sit in the various brands. Decide on the brand and model and if money is an issue just buy the model you want used a few years older.

If you by new, get the 5 yr extended warranty on the outboard (early in the season many
offer a 5 year extended in the deal for free).

Like I said, for me I figured the extra dollars for the Lund over say an Alumacraft if I paid 3k more over the Alumacraft and I plan to keep a rig for 5 years minimum, that's about $20 extra a week to go first class in the Lund!

I'm still planning on upgrading to a 22 foot aluminum boat with a cuddy, but I'll never sell the Lund :D

And on the rivets. Lund has a lifetime warranty on it's hull. If you beach an aluminum boat and scrape rocks or pound the hell out of the hull on the waves of course the hull will eventually leak. But I don't treat my toys like that. Might be in 30 years I might see a rivet leaking. I like the secure feeling of a riveted rig. All "fully" welded boats are nice, but expensive.
 

leer94

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
39
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Thanks everyone! I have been going to a few boat shows to see what else is out there and pricing some boats. Does anyone have or have experience with G3 boats? I have a friend who has one and he really likes his. But other than that I haven't heard much about them. Any additional input is useful.

same here...know a few guys who have them, I have never heard the complain about them, but cannot say I have anymore than second hand occasional knowledge of the G3
 

Expidia

Commander
Joined
Aug 26, 2006
Messages
2,368
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

G3 might be a great boat . . . I have no idea because I've never seen one. What I would be concerned with is it's resale value if they have such a thin market for them.

Check out the G3 thread on Iboats. Not a lot of activity even if it's recently newly added. Something like 9 replies.

http://forums.iboats.com/G3_Boats

Now do the same for a well known brand here on Iboats and higher interest/activity with a popular brand helps to hold up your resale. That goes for outboard brands too!

You'll probably be in the market for another boat in a few years no matter what you buy in an aluminum rig now. I had two other aluminums before I bought my Lund.
 

SKYCRANE

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Dec 22, 2007
Messages
34
Re: Looking to buy a new aluminum boat

Look into the Alumacraft Pro 175. I think it will meet all you needs for the type of fishing that you do. Aumacraft dealers sell the boats as a package deal, Yamaha 50TLR motor with internal mounted 16 gal. fuel tank, Lowrance fishfinder, Minn Kota 40 trolling motor, 2 live wells, rod box, and 3 equipment storage areas along with waterproof storage under the seat area, but the thing I like the most about it is that it is a modified V hull design so it will go in much more shallow water than a standard V hull will. Max speed around 32 mph. According to the stats I have read the Yamaha 50 will go around 100 miles on the water before needing refuel (With the 16 gal tank). I really enjoy mine.
 
Top