Marine CB or VHF?

jerryt

Cadet
Joined
Dec 25, 2007
Messages
16
Which one do you recommend?
Can you use the CB to contact the coast guard?
 

jerryt

Cadet
Joined
Dec 25, 2007
Messages
16
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

Although I did get a lot of info from that thread, I was still a bit confused:confused:

The VHF seems to be for emergency use only? correct?

The CB could be used to talk to other boaters, but can
the CB be used for emergency contact like channel 16 on VHF?


Thanks for any info:)
 

ziggy

Admiral
Joined
Jun 30, 2004
Messages
7,473
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

Can you use the CB to contact the coast guard?
the cg monitors vhf channel 16. all boaters with a vhf radio monitor channel 16. if ya want to get in touch with the cg i think vhf wil be the choice..... my used boat came with a cb. it was replaced with a vhf. cb may have been the choice in '75. but not '08.......
 

Pursuit2150

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Dec 3, 2001
Messages
553
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

I ditto,Ziggy & youcan only talk other boaters on your CB, if they hane one
I don't know anyone that uses a CB.
 
D

DJ

Guest
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

USCG does not monitor CB, only VHF.

You may be able to talk to other boaters, via CB, if they are equipped too.
 

manofprawnz

Seaman
Joined
Nov 10, 2007
Messages
59
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

Forget the CB. At one time there were a lot of CB's on the water, but that is not the case anymore. Suppose they are alright if you want to chat between you and your buddies, but can do the same with the FRS radios or cell phones. That being said, everyone should consider having a VHF radio on board, especially now that you can get a hand held for around $100.

Sorry but did not read where you are from, so not sure if a VHF radio course is manditory, however it is a good idea to take one. There are calling and talking channels, all which will be covered in your local course, however do not hog the frequency for hours on end discussing trivial matters, that is what you cell phone is for.

Some main advantages of VHF are:

The Coast Guard monitors channel 16, they also have direction finding equipments that is very good at pinpointing location in the event of an emergency.

Other boaters maintain a watch on the VHF, and can render assistance if needed.

New Digital VHF equipment can me tied in with GPS, even an inexperienced radio operator can hit the emergency button and send a distress signal with location.

You will recieve broadcasts with warnings such as weather or navigational hazzards.

You can listen in and find out where the fish are.

As for cell phones, they are great, but depending on where you are, coverage may be limited.
 

achris

More fish than mountain goat
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
27,468
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

I suspect there is some confusion about 'CB'. There are two frequency ranges within the 'CB' band. The first is the lower part of the 27Mhz range, the type we associate with truckers and kids playing. The upper end of the 27Mhz band is designated as 'Marine CB'. This is an 'AM' band and 'SSB' is not permitted. It occupies the range 27.680 Mhz to 27.980 Mhz.

In Western Australia it is compulsory to carry a 'marine band radio' on any boat venturing out beyond 5 nautical miles from the coast. It doesn't matter if it's a Marine CB or VHF (I carry both). Most boats here carry the Marine CB (because the sets are cheaper!) and all coast stations monitor the distress frequency, 27.88 Mhz (Channel 88) as well as the marine VHF. There is also an aviation VHF as well, but we won't get into that here.

So, back to the original question... are you talking Marine CB or non marine?

Chris..............
 

BillP

Captain
Joined
Aug 10, 2002
Messages
3,290
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

VHF isn't just for calling the USCG. It has many channels for taking to others. One channel is normally monitored by everyone to call or hear someone calling you. When contact is made you "go to" another channel for normal conversation. Mid priced radios have the channels identifed on the screen for what their use is. Entry level radios only give the channel number and you have to learn what the channel numbers are for.

About CB, not many boats use it where I live but at one time I carried it and VHF. The idea for CB is it will skip out and can get response when your VHF may not have the power or range to do it. I used CB once to raise an over the road trucker who was 75-100 miles away (I was 15 miles out on the flats at Marathon, Fl Keys and he was driving on I-95 in Ft Lauderdale) and he arranged a tow for me. My VHF had died but the radio shack CB was working.

bp
 

achris

More fish than mountain goat
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
27,468
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

I used CB once to raise an over the road trucker who was 75-100 miles away .....

This is not a marine CB. This is a radio that uses the lower end of the CB frequency spectrum. Marine CBs will not communicate with 'trucker' type CBs as they use different frequencies.

All that said, if you are in trouble any method that is effective in getting help is valid. Even 3 gunshots at one second intervals is a valid and international recognised distress call.

Chris..............
 

BillP

Captain
Joined
Aug 10, 2002
Messages
3,290
Re: Marine CB or VHF?

This is not a marine CB. This is a radio that uses the lower end of the CB frequency spectrum. Marine CBs will not communicate with 'trucker' type CBs as they use different frequencies.

All that said, if you are in trouble any method that is effective in getting help is valid. Even 3 gunshots at one second intervals is a valid and international recognised distress call.

Chris..............

A marine only band cb is useless where I live...they've never been popular on boats here. I was one of only guys around with a cb on my boat and that was over 20 yrs ago...it came out of my car. The only good chance of contact with cb from a boat is though the "truckers" 26.965-27.405 freqs and pray it skips. A marine cb that does dual freqs is what to buy if you want to do a cb on a boat. Then you'll have the marine freqs for being pc and the truckers freqs for being rescued.
 
Top