Re: Merc 4HP Gnat running, shift issue
You can't reuse the seals (they get boogered when you remove them), and there is no seal available that I know of to eliminate the shift shaft hole. The shift mechanism should be very simple and if you're willing, should be no problem to take the lower unit apart if need be to get it shifting. If you plan on using this motor for a long time, it would be good to replace those old seals either way. A well-sealed lower unit is nice to have. I think Mercury liked to use reverse threads on the carrier nut, if it has one.
JBJ