If you flip the carb over will it hold vacuum at the inlet? That's the test my carb book has. And I am not home but I recall 15/64 as correct float height on my qjet. Which is not for the same engine so, who knows.
Were both carbs old rebuilds? Were both spec'd for your engine, jets, etc? I will be able to help you later. If you want to talk we can phone when I get home. I feel pretty confident on marine qjets. Send me a PM if you'd like.