Re: Mercury impeller replaced motor always in gear
Welcome to the forum. You have misaligned the shift shaft to the upper shift rod. That's why it won't shift to the other gears.
To fix the problem, pull the lower unit back down, and turn the shift shaft by hand (use pliers/vice grips cushioned so they won't mar the shaft) to Neutral. From Fwd gear, go CCW until you feel resistance then a detent, this should be Neutral. Verify by rotating the prop. Make sure the remote control box is also shifted to Neutral and reinstall the lower unit.
For more info on this very common problem, use the forum's search tools. Do a search, for example on "stuck in forward" and you'll see tons of results which explain this issue and the fix for it in great detail.
HTH..............ed