W's war

txswinner

Banned
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
2,326
6 more young American soldiers are dead. They are heros to all America but they are dead to their families. This thing must be ended.
 

RubberFrog

Rear Admiral
Joined
Apr 9, 2005
Messages
4,268
Re: W's war

You're right, txs. What is your plan for bringing the troops home?<br /><br />Cut and run?
 

jtexas

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Oct 13, 2003
Messages
8,646
Re: W's war

I'd like to express my condolences to the families separately from commenting on the war. That's just my preference.<br /><br />But isn't this the word you're looking for: "casualties"? It's a little less...formal.
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,430
Re: W's war

I'm sure that their Families are Very Saddened by all that's happening,...........<br /><br />I Know that there's a Very SAD Family just up the street from me,.......<br />Their 20 year old Son, was Killed in a Training Accident off the coast of Africa..............<br />Now,...... That Is a Waste,............<br /><br />But,.......<br />I Doubt that they're Any Sadder than the Families of the Several THOUSAND Civilians that Died on September the 11th of 2001...................<br /><br />Our War Casualities Still haven't reached the Death Toll of That DAY.......<br />That's the Unfortunate thing about War,........ People Die..........<br /><br />Note to self,...................<br />Never Again click on a thread or post by txwhiner................................ :rolleyes:
 

txswinner

Banned
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
2,326
Re: W's war

jtexas, your compassion is well taken, but it is time to cut the cr...p and say what it is. These soldiers have died. They are not number 2000+, not acceptable casualties, passing heros, standards of moral turpitude; to their families they are gone. Yes we try to rationalize as do they but the truth aways comes back that a father, son, mother, daughter, brother sister, aunt, uncle fiance, best friend is no longer with us. Tell me why this is justified.<br /><br />Do not give me the anti-America anti-troop bs, this is pure and simple anti-administration.<br /><br />Latex, Hard question as I have no real idea what all W has us into and where we stand as to the ability to get out of Iraq, but I sure as heck would be looking.<br /><br />Latex, Question: Is this what you thought we were getting into when this administration told us we were invading to remove the threat of attack on the US? Not the OSL issue the get rid of Saddam part!!!<br /><br />Yes, I am way out there today and I cry ever time I read about these soldiers dying. It brings back terrible memories for me.
 

heycods

Captain
Joined
Nov 11, 2005
Messages
3,941
Re: W's war

Nice start. And thier off and running. :D ;) <br /><br /> My deepest sympathy to the familys :(
 

eeboater

Commander
Joined
Jul 19, 2004
Messages
2,644
Re: W's war

It's not W's war, it's America's war. They want us dead, please tell me you cannot contest that tx. <br /><br />If I had to make the choice between us going over there to fight, and them coming over here to fight - I think we should go over there, as we did.<br /><br />I'm not a fan of doing things half-a**. That, unfortunately, is what many people in this country think should happen. The sitcom mentality where everything should be done in 30 minutes and it should have a happy ending is running rampant.<br /><br />I don't understand... you are suggesting that we just 'end' a war? You say you fought in Vietnam, and I commend and honor you for that. You did something that I know for a fact I will never be able to do. True, Vietnam was before I was born - but from every account I have heard or read about people say we didn't pull out of that country right. Why would you want to do that again? Why don't you want us to FINISH what we started?<br /><br />Again, there is a big difference between finishing something and finishing something properly. The cut-and-run mentality that people have been displaying since we begun this war is quite disheartening.<br /><br />
Do not give me the anti-America anti-troop bs, this is pure and simple anti-administration.
What I think of when I read that is that you are letting your hate for President Bush, sway your decision on how to do the right thing in this war. In my opinion, that is not right.<br /><br />In recent months, I've been staying away from threads like these because they end up turning into an all-out flame war which is not worth my time and effort. But honestly, I'm tired of hearing people b*tch and moan about this. I feel like I'm with a group of 4th graders that are upset about the fact that they signed up for a summer soccer program, and no longer want to do it anymore because it requires too much physical effort.<br /><br />Like it or not, the World looks to the USA as a standard of excellence. When catastrophe strikes, all eyes are on us to see what we'll do. As much as all the deluded people who think the UN or any other country has any sort of power, they don't. This isn't delusion, its fact. I find it stupifying that certain people in America HATE America because of this.<br /><br />I am not questioning your patriotism or any of that... what I am questioning is your ability to finish something when it starts to get "tough."<br /><br />It's the soldiers job to risk his life to serve and protect the security of our country. I'm sure you know all about that. When our computer network happens to go down in our company, my coworkers don't say:<br /><br />"You know, I feel bad for Sean, how about we let him stop making him take care of the computers. We'll force him to get us just barely up and running, but we'll rely on other people to finish what he started." <br /><br />When Katrina hit New Orleans, it was the police's job to stay and maintain peace and order. The police fled (inappropriately I might add) and look what happened.<br /><br />When 9-11 happened, police & fire did NOT flee... look what happened. <br /><br />Two totally different outcomes.<br /><br />Yep, it sucks that soldiers are dieing. But it is war. We're not playing checkers.<br /><br />Sean
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: W's war

Whomever else's war it may be, it is MY war, too.<br /><br />I voted for him; I supported his decision to go; I support his decision to stay and finish the job.<br /><br />When it was my turn, I went and was willing to die for my country and for liberty if it came to it. I am sure all of the young men and women that are there and those that have died feel the way I did and do.<br /><br />Thank goodness there are those who will fight for liberty and pay whatever the price may be. <br /><br />I don't for the life of me understand those who use that liberty to complain about the price.
 

RubberFrog

Rear Admiral
Joined
Apr 9, 2005
Messages
4,268
Re: W's war

Originally posted by txswinner:<br />Latex, Question: Is this what you thought we were getting into when this administration told us we were invading to remove the threat of attack on the US? Not the OSL issue the get rid of Saddam part!!!
Short answer:no.<br /><br />But we're in there now and there is no quick way out.
 

txswinner

Banned
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
2,326
Re: W's war

Latex, your honest and straight answer is appreciated and I wish I could have answered your question of me as clearly.<br /><br />eeboat, you are right that you have heard. As in Viet Nam there is no victory to be won as the enemy does not exist. There is no goal when it all about the greed of power seekers.<br /><br />How could we win Vietnam, they did not want democracy, where was communism to spread from as it was a *****ula leading to no where. We were not invaded and they posed no threat to the US militarily.<br /><br />What is victory in Iraq. The only thing the Iraqi's agree on is they want us out. BS on the few radicals are causing all the problems, that is what was said about the Americans who wanted us home from Vietnam.<br /><br />I never got spit on when I got home although many of my friends took me out and told me they felt I was an honorable for serving. Not near as bad as press made out. No victory party except for Brown and Root the big VN contractor. Check out George R. Brown, Lyndon and Ladybird. Yeah they were Democrats.<br /><br />I did get bleed on, try to stuff my comrades guts back in, saw bady parts torn off, heads blown open, and it is like it happened yesterday as the stories come out.<br /><br />There is no honorable way out because we went in under false pretense with no plans. That is what happens when chickenhawks and greedy people start wars.<br /><br />I need to go puke.
 

CJY

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Jun 19, 2005
Messages
1,242
Re: W's war

I'm not a fan of doing things half-a**.
I can agree with you on this point EE. However, W has been going about the war half a22ed since the beginning, otherwise it would have been ended long ago.<br /><br />This war cannot be won, only lost. The difference between all of you with the belief we must stay and myself believing we must get out is our belief in the "plan." <br /><br />Even though none of us have ever heard of the "plan" to end this and get out, you believe one exists while I do not.<br /><br />As far as being politically correct with death vs casualty. I wonder if they call it a casualty while the eulogy is being given. I wonder if it is less painful when the casket is being lowered into the Earth. I wonder if looking at your "casualty" for the final time before closing the casket is any less painful. What I really wonder is if these "casualties" will all be worth it when we pull out while having accomplished nothing more than we accomplished after the first month or so.<br /><br />
The sitcom mentality where everything should be done in 30 minutes and it should have a happy ending is running rampant.<br />
What confuses me is the mentality that we can fix things for everybody around the world while we cannot fix issues in out own back yard.<br /><br />I seem to remember W standing in front of the camera shortly after the attack making the declaration of "the war is over." Just more bull. <br /><br />
If I had to make the choice between us going over there to fight, and them coming over here to fight - I think we should go over there, as we did.<br />
Iraq did not bring the war to us, we brought it to them. The person responsible for attacking us here is sitting on a beach drinking a margarita somewhere with little concern from our almighty W.<br /><br />
Why don't you want us to FINISH what we started?<br />
Emphasis on the "what we started" part. I think this says a great deal.<br /><br />
but from every account I have heard or read about people say we didn't pull out of that country right. Why would you want to do that again
Did we win in Vietnam? They raised the white flag and became a Democracy? All of Vietnam?<br /><br /><br />I'm not sure that we all understand death and its finality. As EE stated, this is not a sit-com and things are not ok after 30 minutes. We entered with no plan, have no plan today, and will have no plan tomorrow. It's tough to draw up a plan when you don't know when it is won.<br /><br />Many victories have been claimed; the statue of Sadaam being toppled, purple fingered voters, etc. But it still appears today in Iraq as it did shortly after Sadaam was removed.<br /><br />We will end up pulling out with little accomplished. The difference of later vs. sooner is more death.
 

NOSLEEP

Commander
Joined
Oct 30, 2002
Messages
2,442
Re: W's war

I wont post about how I feel about you comments<br />txswinner. But I will say your experiences in Vietnam <br />has left you one delusional messed up individual. <br />Hope you can live with yourself comfortably.
 

QC

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
22,783
Re: W's war

What EE said. Awesome Sean!!<br /><br />I have only one question for txs and CJY, but they won't answer. Are the people that we are fighting really bad and do they do really bad stuff? I promised I wouldn't use the "evil" word again as it freaks out those that can't answer the question . . . ;)
 

dogsdad

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Messages
1,293
Re: W's war

txs, do you ever get tired of stirring up disagreement and hard feelings?<br /><br />Don't you have anything constructive to do?<br /><br />You, sir, are a troll, a troublemaker, and an agitator, and I can see no purpose for this kind of topic being posted on a daily basis except to do further damage to this country.<br /><br />I refuse to take part in any of your troublemaking in the future.
 

tommays

Admiral
Joined
Jul 4, 2004
Messages
6,768
Re: W's war

Its really simple to me I DONT see how we can make it stable with out enough troops to have COMPLEAT control over there boarders.<br /><br /><br />Outside people who hate us and want this to fail are free to come and go and seem to be able to bring in and unlimited supply of bomb makeing materials and move about the country freely.<br /><br /><br />Until that is stoped i dont see it becomeing stable<br /><br /><br />tommays
 

txswinner

Banned
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
2,326
Re: W's war

QC, You have been asked before pls identify who we are fighting. Did you forget Al Quada and OSL, W has, Cheney has, Rumsfeld has, They have spoken OSL is not important, it is not about one man. Really then why did we send all our troops to Iraq to find Saddam but so few search for OSL. Maybe it is black, comes from the ground and makes them rich and powerful.<br /><br />Dogsdad, You are a simple name caller and your comments always bleat the same blind mindset. To you there is no hope. If you are under 35 you should sign up and go as a soldier, if over that maybe you can get a guard job or just stay home and play CHICKENHAWK.<br /><br />Nosleep, I should have run off and lived in Canada like you. No question my position and mindset are greatly effected by my history. What probably would surprize you is that my economic life is very healthy and I live quite well. Unlike you I do not believe in living off the sacrifices of others.
 

dogsdad

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 8, 2003
Messages
1,293
Re: W's war

One last time, for you txs. I served. That does not give me the right to tell the folks who did not to shut up because they did not. Get the message?<br /><br />I find your continual anti-American bleating and agitating offensive, and your ongoing use of innuendo and baseless accusations revolting. Anyone can see that you are employing the old "tell the lie over and over again until they believe it" tactic.<br /><br />If it walks like a troll, talks like a troll, sounds like a troll...it is a troll.<br /><br />Good day.
 
Top