So what it the WOT Rpm Range for your motor? 5000-5500, 4500-5500?
Try the 12, will bring the Rpms down, if it doesn't an you are still hitting 5800, you have to add more Pitch.
As for the 3000lb vs, your 2300lb. I will assume the 3000lb was referring to non-pontoon boats. What works on...