The starter in the 3rd picture would have been off a much newer motor.-----A 1969 and newer 3 cylinder 55 / 60 / 65 / 70 HP or a 1971 to 2005 model 2 cylinder 50 HP.-----I have never seen or knew it could fit on a 35 HP like yours.------The starter for your 35 was used on the 28 / 33 / 40 hp...